
Janet Jackson had a point, and the old tune put it plainly: The best things in life are free. She was probably singing about love and friendship rather than out-of-contract footballers, but in the summer of 2012 the line fitted English football rather well.
Money was tight. Clubs well beyond the Football League were checking the back of the sofa for loose change, Rangers had collapsed into liquidation and been forced to restart in the bottom tier of Scottish football, and the Bosman ruling had long since turned the end of a contract into a market of its own. So here, taken literally, is a starting eleven of the best free moves made across Europe that summer, along with what happened to them next.
Goalkeeper and defence
GK Robert Green (West Ham United to Queens Park Rangers)
Green will always be the keeper who let Clint Dempsey's weak shot squirm past him in Rustenburg at the 2010 World Cup, a 1–1 draw with the United States that set the tone for England's tournament. That was unfair on a goalkeeper of real authority. At QPR he arrived as experienced cover and competition for a side trying to stay in the top flight, though Mark Hughes then brought in Júlio César and Green spent long spells on the bench. QPR went down at the end of 2012–13.
DF Lúcio (Inter Milan to Juventus)
Thirty-four, a World Cup winner with Brazil in 2002 and a Champions League winner with Inter in 2010, Lúcio had lost a yard of pace from that long, loping stride. The positional sense remained, and so did the habit of galloping forward with the ball, which was always worth the admission money. The Turin move did not last: he left Juventus for São Paulo before the season was half over.
DF Steven Whittaker (Rangers to Norwich City)
Rangers' financial implosion handed bargains to clubs all over Britain. Whittaker declined to stay with the reformed club, and the Scotland right-back joined Chris Hughton's Norwich, who were hoping to build on an impressive first season back in the Premier League.
DF José Bosingwa (Chelsea, released)
Chelsea paid a reported £16.2 million for the Portugal full-back four years earlier, and he started the 2012 Champions League final in Munich. Still, Stamford Bridge no longer wanted him. At 29 he had good years left, or so it seemed. He signed for QPR that August, the same struggling squad Green had joined, and it went badly for both.

Midfield
MF Riccardo Montolivo (Fiorentina to AC Milan)
Alongside Andrea Pirlo, Montolivo kept the ball away from England for long stretches of the Euro 2012 quarter-final in Kyiv, which Italy won on penalties after a goalless 120 minutes. His cultured passing was meant to help Milan replace Pirlo and the departed Clarence Seedorf. He went on to captain the club.
MF Steven Davis (Rangers to Southampton)
Probably the biggest name to leave Ibrox in the exodus, the former Rangers captain and Northern Ireland international gave a newly promoted Southampton midfield something it badly needed: calm. He became a fixture at St Mary's for years before eventually returning to Rangers.
MF Danny Murphy (Fulham to Blackburn Rovers)
Bouncing back from relegation is hard, and Steve Kean was under pressure from the first day at Ewood Park. Murphy brought ideas to a midfield that had run out of them as Rovers sank in 2011–12. Kean was gone by the end of September.
MF Clarence Seedorf (AC Milan to Botafogo)
After ten years at Milan, the 36-year-old signed a two-year deal in Rio de Janeiro that was described as the most lucrative ever handed to a foreign player in Brazil. It was a coup for a league usually treated as a stepping stone to Europe. Seedorf's next move was a surprise of a different kind: in January 2014 he went back to Milan as head coach.
MF/FW Alan Smith (Newcastle United to MK Dons)
Persuading a former England international to drop into League One is difficult; persuading him to choose Milton Keynes is harder still. Karl Robinson managed it. Smith had already spent the previous season on loan at stadium:mk, scoring twice in 18 appearances, and once his Newcastle contract expired he made the move permanent, bringing versatility and experience that were rare in the third tier.

Attack
FW Didier Drogba (Chelsea to Shanghai Shenhua)
Under André Villas-Boas, Drogba spent much of the season brooding on the bench, and his departure looked sensible. Then Villas-Boas was sacked, Roberto Di Matteo took over, and the two-time Premier League top goalscorer turned into the player of old. He scored in the FA Cup final against Liverpool, headed the late equaliser against Bayern Munich in the Champions League final and then struck the winning penalty in the shoot-out. China was supposed to be a long Indian summer. It lasted about six months before he moved on to Galatasaray, and he later returned to Chelsea for one more season in 2014–15.
FW Michael Owen (Manchester United, released)
The electric pace that terrified Argentina in Saint-Étienne in 1998 had long gone. The finishing had not, as three goals from only four starts for United in 2011–12 suggested. Used in rotation, a 32-year-old Owen still looked a shrewd pick-up for a club pushing for the top half. He ended up at Stoke City, and retired at the end of the 2012–13 season.
The substitutes' bench
A free-transfer bench would hardly be short of quality either:
- GK Craig Gordon (Sunderland, released)
- DF Carlos Cuéllar (Aston Villa to Sunderland)
- MF Paul Pogba (Manchester United to Juventus)
- MF Gennaro Gattuso (AC Milan to Sion)
- MF Seydou Keita (Barcelona to Dalian Aerbin)
- MF/FW Salomon Kalou (Chelsea to Lille)
- FW Pavel Pogrebnyak (Fulham to Reading)
- FW Mladen Petrić (Hamburg to Fulham)
- FW Hugo Rodallega (Wigan Athletic to Fulham)
One name on that list aged better than the rest. Pogba left Old Trafford for nothing, won four Serie A titles in Turin and returned to Manchester United in 2016 for a world-record fee. The most expensive free transfer ever made, measured backwards. For more names that moved around, try the guess the player from their transfer history quiz, or the summer churn behind twenty managerial changes in ten Championship months. The debate over whether relegated clubs should be paid at all is covered in the case for rewarding relegation, which QPR fans of 2013 may read with a wince.
Please gamble responsibly. GambleAware.org 18+