
Match of the Day has its problems. The format has barely changed since the first programme in August 1964, and by 2013 the competition from Sky Sports had made a lot of its analysis look dated. Gary Neville's tactical breakdowns on Monday Night Football had shown what television punditry could be, while the Saturday night sofa still too often relied on the adjective-heavy observations of Alan Shearer and Alan Hansen.
Despite those faults, the programme remained the best source of top-flight football for anyone without a satellite subscription. And that season the producers had at least started to experiment with how the same old information was presented.
A programme trying to freshen up
Refreshed graphics, discussions from the side of the pitch, more interviews and new faces in the pundits' chairs all helped stop the show from going completely stale. Martin Keown was one of those new faces, an occasional replacement for the regulars who broke the monotony of seeing the same people every week.
Keown knew the game from the inside, and few defenders are more closely tied to the Arsenal crest. He had two spells at Arsenal either side of stints at Aston Villa and Everton, won the league and FA Cup under Arsène Wenger and was part of the squad that went through the 2003–04 Premier League season unbeaten. He played for England at the 1998 and 2002 World Cups and at Euro 2000. Most supporters, however, remember one image above all: Keown leaping over Ruud van Nistelrooy at Old Trafford in September 2003 after the Dutchman had missed a late penalty.
The stare
That intensity never left him. On the Match of the Day sofa Keown greeted every question with a burning glare. His answers were delivered in a tone so grave that viewers could be forgiven for thinking somebody's life depended on them.
His eyes were the real story. Wide and unblinking, they drew the audience into a sombre world where a few chaps chatting about the weekend's games became something far more serious. A neatly trimmed beard and a sharp department-store suit were presumably intended to soften the effect. If anything they made it stranger, although they did at least distract attention from Shearer's taste in shirts.

The attempt to package him for a broad Saturday night audience did not entirely work. Dressing the most ferocious centre-half of his generation in a smart suit was a bit like putting a medieval warlord in a pink tutu and hoping nobody noticed the sword. Keown remained, unmistakably, a wolf in sheep's clothing, and that intensity was always going to come with him to the Brazil World Cup the following summer.
Better than the alternative
None of this is to say his analysis was poor. Keown's points were often well observed and creative, especially on defending, where he could explain positioning and body shape with a precision the regulars rarely bothered with. Co-commentary had the opposite problem at the time, with a gloomy seriousness that added little. The trouble was that by the time he reached his conclusion, his eyes had already gone straight through the screen and into the viewer's nervous system.
Watching him could feel like a scene from Poltergeist, with the former defender threatening to climb out of the television set. Even so, his presence was more welcome than yet another round of bland verdicts from the regulars. A pundit who cares too much is better than one who does not seem to care at all, and anyone who sat through the duller stretches of terrestrial coverage in that era will understand the appeal.
The years since have backed up that judgement. Hansen left Match of the Day after the 2014 World Cup, the programme slowly made room for sharper voices, and Keown carried on as a television analyst, his stare as fixed as ever. For a while in 2013, though, there was a simple rule for Saturday nights on BBC One: if Keown was on Match of the Day, it was fright night.