
Weekend football on British terrestrial television in early 2013 came in two flavours. The BBC had the Premier League highlights on Match of the Day. ITV had live FA Cup action, a contract it held from 2008 until the BBC won the competition back in 2014. In theory that was a feast for anyone without a satellite dish. In practice, viewers on the weekend of 9 and 10 March were left wondering which channel could extract the least insight from the most football.
Neither was short of famous faces. Gary Lineker fronted Match of the Day with Alan Shearer and Alan Hansen alongside him, while Adrian Chiles anchored ITV's coverage. The trouble was what they said, or rather what they did not.
Match of the Day and the art of stating the obvious
Match of the Day has been on air since August 1964, when the first edition showed Liverpool beating Arsenal 3–2 at Anfield. By 2013 the format had barely moved: highlights, a few minutes of punditry, a joke from the presenter, repeat. The criticism was rarely about the football clips. It was about the analysis around them.
Shearer in particular had become a lightning rod. The complaint from viewers was a familiar one: he would describe what had just been seen, call a defender's mistake "poor" or a goal "great", and move on without telling anyone why. Hansen, who had built his reputation as a sharp critic of defending, was in the final stretch of his long run on the programme and sometimes seemed to be running on muscle memory. Lineker kept things moving with a pun and a raised eyebrow.
It was all very comfortable. That was the problem. The studio felt like a club with its own rules, and the viewer was rarely invited in.
Shearer had, of course, spent a brief spell on the other side of the fence in 2009, called away from the sofa to manage Newcastle United for the last eight games of a season that ended in relegation, a story told in five hard-working managers and their pratfalls. It gave him a front-row seat to how hard the job is, though not much of that experience ever seemed to reach the screen.

ITV's FA Cup: a different studio, the same problem
ITV's coverage brought live football, which should have been an advantage. The FA Cup quarter-finals that weekend offered genuine drama, with Wigan Athletic on their way to an unlikely trophy and the competition still capable of upsets. The studio struggled to match it. Chiles, a warm and likeable presenter who had made his name on the BBC, often seemed to be hosting a chat show that happened to have a football match in the middle of it.
The channel's football studios had been a regular target. Its Euro 2012 set-up drew plenty of comment, as covered in the review of ITV's Euro 2012 studio, and the co-commentary on both channels had developed a gloomy, joyless tone picked apart in when co-commentary became such a serious business.
Sky, Neville and the bar being raised
What made the terrestrial offering look tired in 2013 was the competition. Since 2011 Gary Neville had been on Sky Sports' Monday Night Football, standing at a touchscreen and taking apart defensive shapes, pressing triggers and positional errors in detail that Match of the Day had never attempted. Jamie Carragher joined him later that year. For the first time, a mass audience was being shown why goals happened rather than merely that they had.
The BBC eventually responded. Hansen left Match of the Day after the 2014 World Cup, the programme brought in younger pundits and added more tactical segments, and Lineker himself stepped away from the show in 2025 after more than a quarter of a century as presenter.
Back in March 2013, though, the weekend viewer could be forgiven for a little fantasy casting. Clive Anderson as Lineker, perhaps, with a cardboard cut-out of Adam West in for Shearer and Rutger Hauer as Hansen. It would have been more surprising. It might also have been more informative. Earlier eras of football television, from Saint and Greavsie to the Big Match, are looked back on fondly in a review of the Big Match golden age.