Play a quiz
Playmakers

Celtic creativity: Ireland's skilful midfielders after Liam Brady

England struggled to raise a true number ten. Ireland, a country of four million, kept turning out passers with a fighting streak.

First published 19 Sep ’11Revised Oct ’26 8 min read Articles →
AISlim midfielder shaping a left-footed pass on a muddy 1970s pitch with terraces behind (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

In the days before satellite television, when the top flight was still called the First Division, English football had very few foreign players. A handful arrived in the 1970s and a few more in the 1980s, but it took the success of Eric Cantona, Dennis Bergkamp and Jürgen Klinsmann in the 1990s to open the gates properly.

Before that, a foreign signing looked like a big and exotic gamble. There were the Argentines of the late 1970s, Alejandro Sabella, Ricky Villa and Ossie Ardiles, and Dutchmen such as Arnold Mühren and Frans Thijssen at Ipswich. Restrictive UEFA rules and a good deal of suspicion meant English clubs knew little about what continental players could offer. Only 11 players from outside the UK and Ireland started the first Premier League season in 1992.

The Celtic foreigners of English football

For decades the outsiders who brought artistry to English football came from much closer to home. Scots such as Kenny Dalglish, Denis Law and Billy Bremner, and Northern Irishmen such as George Best, had sublime skill but mixed it with a level of commitment and aggression the English recognised. They all flourished.

The same went for the Republic of Ireland. Every big English club of the 1980s seemed to have a couple of Irishmen: Ronnie Whelan, Mark Lawrenson and Michael Robinson at Liverpool, Kevin Sheedy at Everton, Tony Galvin and Chris Hughton at Tottenham Hotspur, and Frank Stapleton, Kevin Moran and Paul McGrath at Manchester United. Liverpool also had a Danish playmaker of the old school in Jan Mølby, but he was the exception.

Those are very different players. The case here is narrower: that Ireland has produced more classic playmakers than any of the home nations. England rarely raises a true number ten, and when it does it tends to waste him, exiling him to the wing (Paul Scholes, Joe Cole), failing to build the side around him (Glenn Hoddle) or watching him self-destruct (Paul Gascoigne). British coaching has long valued running and covering so highly that the selfishness the role needs, staying in the pocket of space between midfield and attack instead of chasing back, is trained out of boys before they turn professional.

Ireland is different, and one theory points to Gaelic games. Gaelic football and hurling demand non-stop physical effort and real skill at the same time, and Irish footballers in every position tend to play with that intensity. The ability is not always there. The fight always is.

AIHurley and leather ball on a wet Irish pitch with tall H-shaped posts behind (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

That explains the hustle that has defined Irish national teams. It also helps explain why the country kept producing midfielders able to win their share of the scrap and still find the killer pass from the hole behind the strikers. Here are six of the best.

Johnny Giles and Liam Brady, the masters

Johnny Giles

Giles is best remembered for his partnership with Billy Bremner in Don Revie's Leeds United, the side rivals called "Dirty Leeds", where he won two league titles and a pile of cups. He started at Matt Busby's Manchester United, and Busby later called the 1963 sale of Giles to Leeds one of his biggest mistakes.

Bremner was the destroyer, Giles the creator, although each could do the other's job when needed. His range of passing let him run games, set the tempo and dictate tactics. He could also look after himself, and his tackling is remembered as clearly as his vision. A deep tactical thinker, he went on to manage Ireland and, more notably, West Bromwich Albion, and later became one of the sharpest television pundits Ireland has had.

Liam Brady

Perhaps the most naturally gifted player the Republic has produced. A good way to explain Brady to younger fans: Jack Wilshere was flattered every time he was compared to the Dubliner. Brady was Arsenal's biggest star in a period without many trophies, though he did win the FA Cup in 1979 alongside two other young Dubliners, striker Frank Stapleton and centre-back David O'Leary. He was voted PFA Player of the Year that same year.

A European tie against Juventus persuaded the Italian club to sign him in 1980. In Turin he played as the trequartista in a team that won Serie A in 1981 and 1982, and he scored the penalty that clinched the 1982 title despite knowing he was about to be sold. His replacement was Michel Platini. Brady stayed in Italy with Sampdoria, Inter and Ascoli before returning to England with West Ham from 1987 to 1990.

His international career was cruel. He was the heart of what many consider Ireland's finest side of the early 1980s, which beat Platini's France and the USSR in Dublin and still missed the 1982 World Cup on goal difference. Spain and the Netherlands blocked the way to Euro 84, and when Jack Charlton finally took Ireland to a tournament in 1988, Brady missed it through injury.

Short spells as manager of Celtic and Brighton did not go well. He found his calling instead as head of youth development at Arsenal, shaping the kind of technical, passing footballer he had been, and the club's young prospects of the early 2010s came through that system.

John Sheridan and Stephen McPhail, the nearly men

John Sheridan

Jack Charlton was openly uneasy with Brady's insistence on passing the ball instead of hitting it long, but he could not leave out a talent like that until age caught up with him. Oddly, once Brady and Ronnie Whelan had gone, Charlton kept picking another classic playmaker, John Sheridan, and used him in the hole where he was most effective.

Never quite top class, perhaps because he lacked pace, Sheridan on his day had vision, excellent passing, a good work rate and an eye for a spectacular goal. The most famous was his strike for Sheffield Wednesday in the 1991 League Cup final against Manchester United, a sweet moment for a Stretford-born player who came through the youth ranks at Manchester City. He also played for Leeds, Oldham and Bolton and won 34 caps, scoring five times.

He played every game for Ireland at the 1994 World Cup and hit the bar during the famous 1–0 win over Italy at Giants Stadium. His most important goal, though, came in a 3–1 qualifying defeat to Spain, because Ireland reached the finals ahead of Denmark on goals scored. Roy Keane and the tireless Andy Townsend kept his cap count lower than it should have been. He went on to a long career in management in the Football League.

AIStand full of fans in green with tricolour flags under a hazy summer sun (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

Stephen McPhail

McPhail was perhaps the first "new Liam Brady", and he never quite lived up to the label. He broke into the Leeds side under George Graham and David O'Leary, part of the generation of Harry Kewell, Jonathan Woodgate, Paul Robinson, Alan Smith, Ian Harte and Lee Bowyer that promised so much more than it won.

A display in Rome against Zdeněk Zeman's Roma in the 1998 UEFA Cup suggested he might be worth the comparison. Here was a startlingly mature young player, happy to put his foot on the ball, slow the game down and then spear a pass into the heart of an Italian defence. Leeds fans still talk about the 60-yard ball he dropped into the path of Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink for a goal against Derby in 1998, which survives as a clip titled McPhail and Hasselbaink, Leeds vs Derby, uploaded by Sheridan8.

Like many playmakers he was inconsistent when young, and niggling injuries meant he never became a certain starter in seven years at Elland Road between 1997 and 2004. After loans at Nottingham Forest and Millwall he dropped down to Barnsley and then joined Cardiff City, where he became captain and a talisman, making 190 appearances by 2011 and returning from a battle with cancer in 2010. A lack of pace limited him to ten Ireland caps.

Andy Reid and Wes Hoolahan, the luxury players

Andy Reid

Usually stuck on the left because of a left foot that worked like a magic wand, Reid was better suited to the point of attack, where his lack of mobility mattered less and his eye for a pass was deadly. His barrel chest seemed to put most coaches off trying.

Steve Staunton did try it with Ireland, and it may have been the one success of Staunton's unhappy spell. Against Germany at Croke Park, Reid played first-time through balls and raking half-volleys and was easily the best player on the pitch. Bobby Robson said afterwards: "If Andy Reid was Argentinean we'd all be cooing over him." Argentina, after all, has a long habit of producing playmakers in Maradona's image.

His club career never matched the talent. He joined Nottingham Forest from the Dublin schoolboy club Cherry Orchard, then moved in and out of favour at Tottenham, Charlton and Sunderland, with loans at Sheffield United and Blackpool, before returning to Forest in 2011. For Ireland he was a regular until Giovanni Trapattoni arrived in 2008. A late-night row in a team hotel in Germany, after the coach broke up a sing-song led by the guitar-playing Reid, was followed by his exclusion, and Trapattoni insisted Reid was a luxury his system of two screening midfielders could not afford. He stayed on 27 caps and four goals.

Wes Hoolahan

Early in the 2011–12 season, newly promoted Norwich City faced Chelsea. Under Paul Lambert, Norwich had lit up the Championship with a passing game built around Hoolahan, whom Lambert had moved from the wing to the tip of a midfield diamond. Norwich lost, but Hoolahan never looked overawed.

He drifted into space, took the ball and moved it on, and three times in the first half he clipped neat passes between Chelsea defenders. John Obi Mikel struggled to get near him. Of all six players here he was perhaps the best dribbler, often surging through midfield with the ball glued to his feet.

AISmall attacking midfielder dribbling past a defender under floodlights in the rain (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

He came through at Shelbourne, winning three league titles between 2001 and 2004, then moved to Livingston, Blackpool and, in 2008, Norwich. In 2011 he had a single cap, as a substitute against Colombia at Craven Cottage in 2009. That changed in the years that followed, and in Paris at Euro 2016 he scored Ireland's goal against Sweden, a sweet first-time volley that summed up everything Trapattoni had been missing.

For more thoughts on football and film, the writer who first made this argument kept a Twitter page, and his short film reviews are collected here.

Questions and answers

What did Liam Brady win at Arsenal and Juventus?

Brady won the FA Cup with Arsenal in 1979 and was voted PFA Player of the Year the same year. At Juventus he won Serie A in 1981 and 1982, scoring the penalty that clinched the second title even though he knew he was about to be replaced by Michel Platini.

Why did Liam Brady never play at a major tournament?

Ireland missed the 1982 World Cup on goal difference despite beating France and the USSR in Dublin, Spain and the Netherlands blocked the way to Euro 84, and when Jack Charlton finally took Ireland to Euro 88, Brady missed it through injury.

Which Irish midfielders have been compared to Liam Brady?

Johnny Giles came before him, and John Sheridan, Stephen McPhail, Andy Reid and Wes Hoolahan followed. All were skilful passers with a fighting streak, though McPhail, often billed as the new Brady, never quite lived up to the label.

Why did Andy Reid stop playing for Ireland?

After Giovanni Trapattoni arrived in 2008, a late-night row in a team hotel, when the coach broke up a sing-song led by the guitar-playing Reid, was followed by his exclusion. Trapattoni called him a luxury his system could not afford, and Reid stayed on 27 caps.

Keep reading

Players

Jan Molby: the Danish playmaker of Liverpool's 1986 FA Cup final

Never slim, rarely hurried and blessed with a left foot like a precision instrument, Jan Molby was the finest passer in a team full of great passers.

Read on →Jan Molby: the Danish playmaker of Liverpool's 1986 FA Cup final
Videos

Former Bolton striker Mixu Paatelainen's prank call in Phoenix Nights

A Finnish centre-forward, a coroner's office and a furious club owner woken in the small hours. Peter Kay's Bolton sitcom at its most local.

Read on →Former Bolton striker Mixu Paatelainen's prank call in Phoenix Nights
Articles

Arsenal's latest crop of rising stars gunning for the first team

While Tottenham were being taken apart in Madrid, Arsenal's reserves were putting on a show at Barnet. Three youngsters caught the eye on a lively April night.

Read on →Arsenal's latest crop of rising stars gunning for the first team