
Maradona. Messi. Riquelme. Ortega. Aimar. Pastore.
Argentina produces a quite unbelievable number of high-quality playmakers. In Argentina the role is called the enganche, which literally means "the hook": the link between midfield and attack. Argentine football gives positions slightly different shirt numbers from the European norm, so a number 5 is a defensive midfielder and a number 8 an all-round midfielder, but the number 10 is so closely tied to the playmaker that the position itself is casually called "the 10".
It is a divisive role. Not everyone believes in the mystique of the 10. Marcelo Bielsa, the former Argentina coach and eccentric genius, has long preferred an 8 in the 10's position, and regarded even a player as sublimely gifted as Juan Román Riquelme as a luxury a team could not afford. In late 2011 Alejandro Sabella, then the national coach, resisted Javier Pastore in his first games in charge, preferring a more prosaic option in José Sosa of Metalist Kharkiv, although he did, of course, pick Lionel Messi, who rarely plays as an out-and-out playmaker.
Sabella's pragmatism worked. Three years later he took Argentina to the 2014 World Cup final in Rio, where they lost 1–0 to Germany after extra time.
An old problem: too many 10s
The 10 is part of Argentina's football heritage, and the production line keeps turning out skilful little playmakers. There are so many, in fact, that Argentine football cannot hold them all. They play right across the Americas, in Europe and in Asia, for famous clubs and tiny ones, in glamorous cities and backwaters, some winning trophies and acclaim, others simply making a living.
Some are well known. The generation of Pablo Aimar and Riquelme also included lesser but still considerable talents such as Daniel Montenegro, Andrés D'Alessandro, Leandro Romagnoli, Federico Insúa and César Delgado, all of whom played in Europe and would probably have won many more caps without the talent ahead of them.
It is an old, old story for Argentine playmakers. Ricardo Bochini is a legend at Independiente, where his precise passing and uncanny eye for a through-ball drove the club to a string of trophies, including four Copa Libertadores titles between 1973 and 1984. Yet he, like the similarly gifted Claudio Borghi, barely played for his country. The reason was a certain Diego Armando Maradona. Bochini's international career amounted to a handful of appearances, the most famous of them a brief cameo in the 1986 World Cup semi-final, when Maradona reportedly greeted him as he came on with the words "Pase, maestro".
After Maradona retired, Ariel Ortega and Marcelo Gallardo competed for years for the right to be the first-choice 10. Ortega won more caps, and Gallardo arguably never quite fulfilled his immense talent as a player, though he more than made up for it later as one of the most successful coaches in River Plate's history.
In 2011 it looked as though the combined talents of Messi and Pastore might mean that the likes of Maxi Moralez, Sebastián Blanco and even Erik Lamela would suffer the same fate. Broadly, that is what happened. Lamela built a fine club career at Roma and Tottenham, Moralez and Blanco made their names abroad, and the national team was built around Messi, who finally won the World Cup in Qatar in 2022.
Below that level, there were brilliant Argentine playmakers scattered all over the world, and especially around Latin America. Six of them, from the autumn of 2011, are worth knowing about.
Jonathan Fabbro: the nomad of El Semillero
The Buenos Aires club Argentinos Juniors is famous for the regularity with which its youth system produces great players. Even the giants of Argentine football, the big five of Boca Juniors, River Plate, Racing Club, Independiente and San Lorenzo, cannot really compete with the output of a club nicknamed El Semillero, "the seed bed" or, more loosely, "the nursery". Maradona, Riquelme and Fernando Redondo, each arguably among the five or ten best Argentine players of recent decades, all came through at Argentinos, alongside Borghi, Esteban Cambiasso, Fabricio Coloccini, Juan Pablo Sorín and Sergio Batista.
Jonathan Fabbro was another, far less celebrated graduate. In 2011 he was an old-fashioned Argentine playmaker who fitted the stereotype almost perfectly: long-haired, whip-thin and maddeningly inconsistent. He was capable of flashes of real brilliance and equally liable to vanish from a game, or worse, to play almost aggressively badly. He had the arrogance every great 10 needs, the self-belief to try the unlikely pass, the outrageous flick or the hopeless dribble. On bad days that meant giving the ball away again and again and spending long spells with his hands on his hips, shaking his head.
For years he was a footballing nomad. He never made the first team at Argentinos, moved to Mallorca in 2002 without playing, and returned home for a brief stint at Boca the same year. He first made a real impression in Colombia with Once Caldas, whom he joined in 2004. Based in Manizales, Once Caldas had been surprise Colombian champions in 2003 and, more surprisingly still, won the Copa Libertadores in 2004 with Fabbro in the squad, though usually as a substitute. That side played a cagey, counter-attacking game and beat Boca on penalties in the final.
Fabbro started the Intercontinental Cup final against Porto in Yokohama at the end of that year and was arguably the classiest player on the pitch, using the ball intelligently every time he had it. The match went to penalties, and he was one of two Once Caldas players to miss as Porto won the shoot-out 8–7. Porto lifted the trophy.
Spells followed with Dorados de Sinaloa in Mexico and, in 2006, brief stays at two big clubs, Atlético Mineiro in Brazil and Universidad Católica in Chile. He finally found a home in Paraguay at Guaraní of Asunción in 2007, becoming the talisman over three seasons and helping the club to its first league title in 26 years in 2010. He then moved to rivals Cerro Porteño, where he played a key role in their run to the semi-finals of the 2011 Libertadores.
His temperament remained the same: a mix of petulance and genius. By late 2011 he had obtained Paraguayan citizenship in the hope of an international call-up, and with Paraguay's biggest weakness being a lack of creativity, the idea had obvious logic. On his day he was a match-winner and one of the most watchable players in the country.

David Ramírez: el Mago, the late bloomer
Argentina is a highly centralised country, and its football even more so. All of the big clubs come from football-mad Buenos Aires, apart from the two giants of Rosario. When a player emerges at a provincial club, however well he plays and however successful the club, the expectation is that he must move to the capital and prove himself at a big team.
That expectation was heightened for David "el Mago" Ramírez because his first truly notable season came at 29, at unfashionable Godoy Cruz in Mendoza Province, near the Chilean border. He had spent a decade drifting around Argentine football, in the lower divisions and the Primera, with spells at the famous old Ferro Carril Oeste and, outside Buenos Aires, at Olimpo and Gimnasia y Esgrima de Jujuy, as well as an earlier season at Godoy Cruz. He also had six months on loan at SD Ponferradina in the Spanish second division in 2006 and a fairly successful year in Chile with Unión Española in 2009.
After returning to Godoy Cruz in 2010, Ramírez suddenly blossomed. He combined elegant movement with physical strength and offered exactly what an enganche should: he scored goals and he made them. Give him the ball around the opposition area and he would almost always slide a team-mate through, and he had a knack of arriving at the right moment to finish moves himself.
Riquelme, injured for most of that season and presumably watching plenty of football as a result, called him the best player in Argentina.
His ten goals in 32 appearances from midfield drove a strong Godoy Cruz side who challenged for the title, played some lovely football and qualified for the Copa Libertadores for the first time in their history with a third-place finish.
Buenos Aires duly noticed. Vélez Sarsfield bought him for around US$3 million in January 2011. Vélez already had an outstanding playmaker in the diminutive Maxi Moralez, with Ricky Álvarez as cover, so Ramírez spent much of that season on the bench. He still made an impact, scoring a stunning goal on his Libertadores debut against Caracas and finishing the season, in which Vélez won the Argentine title and were unlucky to lose to Peñarol in the Libertadores semi-finals, as top scorer with eight goals in 14 games.
By the following season Vélez had sold Moralez and Álvarez, leaving Ramírez with the 10 shirt and, alongside Augusto Fernández, much of the creative burden for a side mounting a strong late run after a shaky start had left them well behind a revitalised Boca. They were also going well in the Copa Sudamericana, the South American equivalent of the Europa League, where neutrals hoped for a meeting with the thrilling Universidad de Chile side who were dazzling the continent with their counter-attacking power game. It was Universidad de Chile who went on to win the trophy that December.
Ramírez, by then 30, admitted that chronic shyness might explain why success had come so late. Had he been Paraguayan, Bolivian or Peruvian, his form would have made him a fixture in the national team. As an Argentine, he had to be content with trophies and praise late in his career.
Any player in South America nicknamed "the wizard" deserves a look anyway. The continent's other prominent mago at the time was the brilliant little Chilean Jorge Valdivia of Palmeiras, and what a player he was.
Walter Montillo: an Argentine star in Brazil
Given the ferocity of the rivalry between the two countries, it is startling how important Argentine playmakers became to the Brazilian championship in the years around 2010. The most notable examples were Darío Conca, the heartbeat of the Fluminense side that won the 2010 Brasileirão before a lucrative move to Guangzhou Evergrande in China, and the much-travelled former "new Maradona" Andrés D'Alessandro, a key player for Internacional of Porto Alegre, with whom he won both the Libertadores and the Copa Sudamericana. Add Darío Bottinelli at Flamengo, Marcelo Cañete at São Paulo, and Manuel Lanzini and Alejandro Martinuccio, both trying to replace Conca at Fluminense, and the trend was impossible to ignore. Lanzini, incidentally, later became a familiar face in England with West Ham United.
Walter Montillo was another. In early 2011, when his Cruzeiro side were playing scintillating attacking football built around his quick feet, thrashing Estudiantes, then the reigning Argentine and South American champions, 5–0, he looked as though he might be the best of the lot.
He began at San Lorenzo, where he spent four years in and out of the first team without ever really shining, before a year on loan at Monarcas Morelia in Mexico in 2006–07 gave him regular football. His return to San Lorenzo coincided with a league title, but he played little and in 2008 he accepted a move to Universidad de Chile for what was then a Chilean record fee of around US$1 million.
As first-choice playmaker at a big club for the first time, Montillo thrived. He had all the attributes of the classic Argentine 10: short and stocky, at around five feet seven, with vision in the final third and the ability to execute the pass, the speed to dribble through opponents and an eye for the spectacular.
In two years at La U he won a title, scored 15 goals in 62 games and impressed many observers in the Libertadores. That was how the Brazilian clubs found him. Flamengo made an offer after he scored against them and generally tormented them in a 2–1 win in Santiago, but it was Cruzeiro he joined, in July 2010. Although his form dipped along with the rest of the team at the start of the 2011 season, he was generally superb, scoring 19 goals in 51 games, creating many more and winning the Troféu Armando Nogueira as the best player in the 2010 Brasileirão.
In September 2011 he was called up to Sabella's squad of home-based players for the second leg of the Superclásico de las Américas against Brazil, and won his first cap. He did not play as well as he might have hoped, but for a man who had never really made it in Argentina, starting as an attacking midfielder against Brazil was no small achievement.

Martín Rolle: the little man of Bahía Blanca
The prevailing wisdom in 2011 was that the growing physicality of Argentine football had changed the profile of its players. Athletes were bigger, stronger and faster than ever, so the classic pint-sized enganche of old, the street urchin with feet quicker than the eye and the ability to spot a gap before anyone else, was becoming rarer. The modern playmaker was more in Riquelme's mould: tall and strong. The Colombian Giovanni Moreno at Racing Club, Erik Lamela, newly sold to Roma after starring at River Plate, and Javier Pastore, who had made his name at Huracán, all seemed to fit the pattern.
The little men still existed, though, and when they played they tended to excel. Maxi Moralez was arguably the best player in Argentina in each of his seasons at Vélez, and Martín Rolle was one of the stars of the 2010–11 season for Olimpo.
Rolle stood around five feet four, but his personality on the pitch more than made up for it. Watching Olimpo at the time meant marvelling at how all their attacking play ran through him: constantly searching for space, taking the ball and giving it, bursting into quick dribbles, setting up one-twos and slyly threading passes through to his strikers.
After his superb performances, many expected Olimpo to lose him to a big Buenos Aires club, but the Bahía Blanca side held on to him for the time being. The glamour and pressure of the capital might not have suited him anyway.
He emerged at Guillermo Brown, a small club from the coastal town of Puerto Madryn in Patagonia, playing in the Torneo Argentino B, a regional league made up of teams from the interior. After two years there he moved in 2003 to the biggest club in his province, CAI of Comodoro Rivadavia, who played in the second tier. Olimpo were also in that division when they signed him in 2009, but they were promoted as champions that season and surprised many by staying up. Rolle was central to it all, the fulcrum of their passing game, with 25 goals in 74 games for the club, a man-of-the-match display that outshone Riquelme in a 2–0 win over Boca Juniors, and every sign that Olimpo would struggle to keep him much longer.
The only question, in late 2011, was which club would make the move.
Pablo Vitti: the chosen one who slipped
The Argentina side that won the 2005 World Youth Championship in the Netherlands was packed with players who went on to fine careers at big clubs: Messi, Sergio Agüero, Fernando Gago, Pablo Zabaleta, Lucas Biglia and Ezequiel Garay, all stars in Europe and full internationals. As with any youth team, others settled for careers at smaller clubs in Argentina and Europe, and some were never quite good enough. Then there is the curious case of Pablo Vitti.
At the time he looked like the chosen one. He started up front in Argentina's first game of the tournament, against the USA, while Messi and Agüero, the youngest members of the squad, began on the bench. Argentina lost 1–0, and Vitti failed to reproduce the form he had shown for other youth sides or for his club, Rosario Central. He was dropped for the next game, Messi and Agüero came in, and their success reduced him to a bit-part role for the rest of the tournament; he did not feature in the semi-final or the final. Messi was top scorer and player of the tournament. Vitti, who had looked a future star beforehand, left disappointed and with his reputation dented.
That was where things started to go wrong. In 2006 he left Rosario Central, where he had worn the 10 shirt and scored 13 goals in 74 appearances over three seasons, for a short and unhappy spell at Banfield, who sold him on to Independiente, where he barely played. Independiente loaned him first to Chornomorets Odesa in Ukraine in 2008 and then to Toronto FC in Major League Soccer in 2009. Other second-tier Argentines played in that league, but as a youngster Vitti had shown signs of being capable of much more, and his eventual sale to Universidad San Martín in Peru suggested he was settling for an easier career in a weaker league.
Instead he excelled. Vitti scored 14 goals in 36 games in 2010 and was widely regarded as the best footballer in Peru that year. That earned him a move to Universitario, one of the country's big two alongside Alianza Lima, where his fine form continued as part of an exciting young side, against a backdrop of financial uncertainty, crowd trouble and almost comic organisational chaos. His position and shirt at San Martín, meanwhile, went to Carlos Marinelli, another journeyman playmaker, another former "new Maradona" and, once upon a time, a notable flop at Middlesbrough.

Lucas Lobos: success after Europe
Mexico has long been a country and a league kind to Argentines. The Mexican economy keeps the league strong and, by Argentine standards, wealthy, without the cultural and language gap that even Brazil presents. The standard of play is similar to Argentina's, which makes it an ideal destination for players who failed in Europe, or were not quite good enough for it, but are too strong for the Argentine league. The most high-profile examples in the years before 2011 were César Delgado and Christian Giménez, both of whom dazzled at Cruz Azul, but there were others.
Lucas Lobos was one. Alongside one of the best names in football, he had a considerable talent, and he was a good example of a gifted South American who could not quite make it in Europe.
He made his debut in 2001 for Gimnasia y Esgrima La Plata, the second club of his home city, and starred there as playmaker until he took the leap to Spain in 2006. A problem many Argentines face when they move to Europe is choosing the right club. Ideally they join a mid-sized top-flight club in Spain or Italy, learn the culture and pace of the game, prove themselves and move on to a bigger club when they are more mature. Pastore's career was the textbook example: a spell at Palermo followed by a big-money move to Paris Saint-Germain in 2011.
Lobos probably hoped for something similar when he chose Cádiz in 2006. They were enjoying one of their rare seasons in La Liga, and the move must have looked attractive: a pleasant lifestyle in a beautiful old city on the Atlantic coast of Andalusia, famously passionate support and little of the pressure he would face at one of Spain's more celebrated football hotbeds. But Cádiz were relegated, and although he performed well enough that season and in the division below, with 15 goals in 47 appearances, once it was clear the club would not bounce straight back he began looking at his options.
He chose Tigres UANL of Monterrey, and the move was a success. Lobos was a solid playmaker. He was perhaps less blessed than some of the others in this list, but he was more consistent and hard-working, still excellent in possession and a fine finisher. By late 2011 he was captain of a Tigres side sitting top of the Mexican league, and that December they won the Apertura title, the club's first league championship in almost three decades. His career was a useful lesson that a failed move to Europe need not mean the end of a career abroad.
The production line keeps turning
All six had one thing in common: the national team was never really an option, because Argentina already had a Messi, a Riquelme or a Pastore in the way. Their careers played out instead in Asunción, Mendoza, Belo Horizonte, Bahía Blanca, Lima and Monterrey, where crowds who rarely saw them on European television knew exactly how good they were.
For a lighter look at some of the continent's great characters, including Riquelme himself, see the cartoon portraits of world football's characters. The next generation of South American hopefuls from the same era is profiled in Latin wonderkids, and the earlier giants of the game feature in the world football sticker quiz.
The author of this scouting guide shares more on South American football and film on his Twitter page and also writes short capsule film reviews here.
Somewhere in a provincial Argentine league this weekend, another long-haired, whip-thin teenager is trying the impossible pass, and probably giving the ball away.