Play a quiz
Rising stars

You never win anything with kids? England's young hopefuls of 2009

Alan Hansen's most quoted sentence was proved wrong within a season. Fourteen years later a new crop of English teenagers was being talked up, with mixed results.

First published 4 Aug ’09Revised Oct ’26 4 min read Articles →
AICones and balls on a frosty training pitch with a lone coach on the touchline (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

On the opening day of the 1995–96 season Manchester United lost 3–1 at Aston Villa with a side full of youngsters, and Alan Hansen delivered his verdict on Match of the Day, a programme with a long line of memorable and less memorable punditry: "You can't win anything with kids." By May, United had won the Premier League and the FA Cup, and David Beckham, Gary Neville, Paul Scholes and Nicky Butt had become the most famous rebuttal in English football punditry.

The line has followed Hansen ever since. It also became shorthand for every summer in which English football worried about whether young homegrown players would ever get a game in a league increasingly stocked from abroad.

The worries of summer 2009

By August 2009 that anxiety was at a peak. England had failed to qualify for Euro 2008, and a popular explanation in the press was that foreign imports were blocking the path of English teenagers. The counter-argument was already on the pitch: Fabio Capello's side were cruising through qualification for the 2010 World Cup, and Premier League clubs were quietly spending on young English talent rather than only on established stars.

One fan writing under the name Paul(No1Fan) called the arrival of Fabian Delph at Aston Villa "shrewd business" from Martin O'Neill, comparing it with the earlier signing of Ashley Young from Watford. Delph had come from Leeds United, then in League One, and was one of a handful of English midfielders being tipped for big things.

There was also a sharper point about foreign influence. Jack Wilshere, the Arsenal teenager, was training every day with Cesc Fàbregas and Andrei Arshavin. Few would argue that was a worse education than the one available a generation earlier.

AIMuddy youth-size boots lined up beneath plain white shirts in a changing room (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

The names on the list

Look back at the young players being talked up that season and the list is a good snapshot of how unpredictable development really is. Among those mentioned at the time:

  • Marc Albrighton and Barry Bannan, both coming through at Aston Villa
  • Kieran Gibbs, the Arsenal full-back
  • Michael Mancienne, a young Chelsea defender
  • Kyle Naughton, newly signed by Tottenham from Sheffield United
  • Jack Rodwell, the Everton midfielder
  • Daniel Sturridge, who had just moved from Manchester City to Chelsea

Federico Macheda belonged in the conversation too, even if he was Italian rather than English. Months earlier, in April 2009, he had come off the bench on his Manchester United debut and curled in a late winner against Aston Villa in a 3–2 win that swung the title race. Everyone expected him to kick on.

Every era has its wonderkids who never quite arrive, from real teenagers to the Championship Manager legends who faded in reality.

What happened next

He did not. Macheda drifted through loans and moves around Europe and never came close to repeating that afternoon at Old Trafford. Rodwell, who earned England caps and a move to Manchester City in 2012, struggled with injuries and slipped away from the top level surprisingly early.

Others went much further than anyone predicted. Albrighton, released by Villa in 2014, joined Leicester City and was a regular on the right of midfield when they won the Premier League in 2015–16, one of the least likely title wins in the history of the sport. Sturridge formed a frightening partnership with Luis Suárez at Liverpool in 2013–14, when they came within a whisker of the title.

Delph won the league with Manchester City under Pep Guardiola, often playing out of position at left-back, and went to the 2018 World Cup with England. Gibbs collected FA Cup winners' medals with Arsenal. Wilshere, the brightest of all of them and the pick of a promising Arsenal academy crop, became an England international and produced the team goal against Norwich in 2013 that still turns up on every list of Arsenal's best, but injuries shaped his career and he retired in 2022 at just 30.

Bannan, meanwhile, became a mainstay at Sheffield Wednesday and a Scotland international. Naughton found a long home at Swansea City.

The lesson Hansen never had to learn twice

The record of any crop of young players is a reminder that being praised at 18 guarantees very little. A late winner on debut, a shrewd transfer, a place in a newspaper list of "ones to watch" all count for less than a run of good luck with injuries and a manager who trusts youth when it matters.

That was what United had in 1995. Alex Ferguson had sold Paul Ince, Mark Hughes and Andrei Kanchelskis that summer and was prepared to lose a few games while the kids found their feet. Hansen's line was not foolish on the evidence of one afternoon at Villa Park. It simply ignored how much faith the man in the dugout had in them.

The same fan, Paul(No1Fan), summed up the more hopeful mood of 2009: it was refreshing to read about football that was not all billion-pound signings and greedy players, because there was plenty of young talent around. On the evidence of Albrighton's medal and Delph's World Cup, he had a point.

Somebody else put it more simply, pointing out that Ray Parlour, the "Romford Pelé" himself, had a few tricks of his own.

Questions and answers

When did Alan Hansen say 'you can't win anything with kids'?

On Match of the Day in August 1995, after Manchester United lost 3–1 at Aston Villa on the opening day with a young side. By May, United had won the Premier League and the FA Cup, with Beckham, Gary Neville, Scholes and Butt at the heart of it.

Why did Alex Ferguson trust young players in 1995?

He had sold Paul Ince, Mark Hughes and Andrei Kanchelskis that summer and was prepared to lose a few games while the youngsters found their feet. Hansen's verdict was not foolish on one afternoon's evidence; it simply underestimated the manager's faith in them.

What happened to Federico Macheda after his Manchester United debut?

In April 2009 he came off the bench on debut and curled in a late winner in a 3–2 win over Aston Villa that swung the title race. Everyone expected him to kick on, but he drifted through loans and moves around Europe and never repeated that afternoon.

Which young English players of 2009 went on to win the Premier League?

Marc Albrighton, released by Aston Villa in 2014, was a regular for Leicester City when they won the title in 2015–16. Fabian Delph won the league with Manchester City under Pep Guardiola and went to the 2018 World Cup with England.

Keep reading

Articles

Arsenal's latest crop of rising stars gunning for the first team

While Tottenham were being taken apart in Madrid, Arsenal's reserves were putting on a show at Barnet. Three youngsters caught the eye on a lively April night.

Read on →Arsenal's latest crop of rising stars gunning for the first team
Articles

The free transfer XI of summer 2012: Green, Lucio, Drogba, Owen

Eleven players who moved for nothing in the summer of 2012, from Rangers exiles to a Champions League final hero, and what became of them.

Read on →The free transfer XI of summer 2012: Green, Lucio, Drogba, Owen
Articles

Championship Manager legends who faded in reality: Moukoko and Samba

On a beige PC they won European Cups single-handed. On grass, their careers took a rather different path.

Read on →Championship Manager legends who faded in reality: Moukoko and Samba