Play a quiz
Goals that weren't

Son Heung-min and the forgotten wonder goals that never counted

Son's disallowed FA Cup strike in 2018 belongs to a long line of brilliant, important or simply ridiculous goals wiped out by a whistle or a flag.

First published 22 Mar ’18 4 min read Articles →
AIBall in a rippling net under floodlights while a distant referee pauses play (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

It had everything a great goal needs: a soft first touch, a fierce strike that thumped in off the crossbar, and a goalkeeper with his arms hanging limp by his sides. Son Heung-min's effort against Swansea City in the FA Cup quarter-final in March 2018 should have been the highlight of Tottenham's afternoon at the Liberty Stadium. Instead referee Kevin Friend, after a long pause for the video assistant, chalked it off. Spurs won 3–0 anyway, and the goal went into the drawer marked "never happened".

That drawer is fuller than most people think. Ask a pub quiz team to name the third man to walk on the moon and watch the shrugs. It was Pete Conrad, who had earlier flown Gemini 11 with Dick Gordon (crew photograph: NASA). Disallowed goals suffer the same fate. Some were beautiful, some were important, a few were both, and nearly all have been quietly removed from the record by a whistle or a raised flag.

Supporters do not mourn them much. A goal that does not count wins nothing. Yet for anyone who loves the game's odd corners, the goals that never were still carry a little joy, and for the players involved, a lingering ache.

Frank Lampard v Germany, Bloemfontein, 2010 World Cup

The most famous ghost goal of the modern era. With England 2–1 down in the last-16 tie at the Free State Stadium, Lampard's chip from the edge of the area hit the underside of the bar and bounced a clear yard over the line. Nobody in an official shirt saw it.

It became the goal that pushed English football's clamour for technology to full volume, and optimists still claim England would have gone on to win. They would not have. Germany were faster, sharper and far better organised, and the 4–1 final score reflected how easily they kept running through to David James's goal. Goal-line technology arrived in the Premier League in 2013–14 and at the World Cup in Brazil a year later, which tells its own story.

Pedro Mendes v Manchester United, Old Trafford, 2005

If any doubt surrounded Lampard's strike in the minutes after it happened, there was none about the one Pedro Mendes launched from near the halfway line in January 2005. Anyone who had wandered off to the bar could still see the ball was well over the line before Roy Carroll scrambled it out.

Carroll had fumbled a dropping ball through his gloves, dived back to claw it from behind the line and then shot a glance towards the assistant referee so loaded with guilt it would have convicted him in any crown court. The goal was not given. The match finished 0–0 and United took a point they had not earned.

AIA wood-effect television showing a blurry football match in a 1980s living room (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

Edinson Cavani v Barcelona, Camp Nou, 2011

An away goal at Barcelona is a treasured thing. An overhead kick away at Barcelona is a mantelpiece memory. An overhead kick that goes in off the bar away at Barcelona is the sort of thing a man might want carved on his headstone. Cavani managed all three for Napoli in the 2011 Joan Gamper Trophy, and the referee disallowed it. Barcelona then scored five, which buried the memory even deeper.

Dani Osvaldo v Lecce, Stadio Olimpico, 2011

English audiences remember Osvaldo as the striker Southampton signed for £12.8 million in 2013, who too often moved like a marathon runner with a fridge strapped to his back and whose contract was ended before two seasons were up. At Roma, against Lecce, he looked a different athlete, leaping like a flea to hook the ball acrobatically into the roof of the net. Disallowed. He pulled his shirt over his face, which was understandable.

Kevin Keegan v Manchester United, The Dell, 1981

"The linesman is there with his arms on his hips," offered Brian Moore on commentary, which only added to the confusion after Keegan's glorious volley was ruled out for Southampton. The official in question wore lapels wide enough to suggest a disco booking after the final whistle. Keegan's outrage was justified, though it was probably softened by the result: Southampton won 3–2.

Cristiano Ronaldo v Spain, Lisbon, 2010

Every park kickabout has one player desperate to be involved in everything. In this case it was Nani. Ronaldo's effort was heading in when his team-mate, standing offside, could not resist touching it over the line during a November 2010 friendly against the world champions.

"I touched the ball because I thought I wasn't offside. Everything happened so quickly," Nani explained afterwards. "After having time to think about it I apologised to Ronaldo. It was a great piece of play and I shouldn't have ruined it." Portugal still won 4–0, which hardly matters to a man as competitive as Ronaldo.

Son, at least, got plenty of goals that did stand. He went on to win the Puskás Award for his slalom run against Burnley in 2019, captained Tottenham, lifted the Europa League with them in 2025 and then left for Los Angeles FC. For other goals that slipped through the cracks of memory, see the other goal and the first mystery goal, or test the memory with the Premier League goalscorer GIF quiz.

Questions and answers

Why was Son Heung-min's goal against Swansea disallowed?

In the FA Cup quarter-final at the Liberty Stadium in March 2018, Son's strike in off the crossbar was ruled out by referee Kevin Friend after a long pause for the video assistant. It mattered little in the end, as Tottenham won 3–0.

Did Frank Lampard's goal against Germany cross the line?

Yes, clearly. At the 2010 World Cup his chip bounced down off the bar a yard over the line, but no official saw it and the goal was not given. Germany won 4–1, and goal-line technology arrived in the Premier League in 2013–14 and at the 2014 World Cup.

What happened with Pedro Mendes's goal at Old Trafford?

In January 2005 the Tottenham midfielder shot from near the halfway line, and Manchester United goalkeeper Roy Carroll fumbled the ball well over the line before clawing it back out. The goal was not given and the match finished 0–0.

Why did Nani's touch cost Cristiano Ronaldo a goal against Spain?

In a November 2010 friendly, Ronaldo's effort was heading in when Nani, standing offside, touched it over the line and the goal was disallowed. Nani apologised afterwards, saying it was a great piece of play he should not have ruined. Portugal still won 4–0.

Keep reading

Articles

The other goal: in praise of the spectacular own goal

Screamers get the montages, but nothing delights a neutral quite like a perfectly executed own goal. A few of the finest, from Maine Road to Craven Cottage.

Read on →The other goal: in praise of the spectacular own goal
Articles

Mystery Goal No.1: a classic goal recreated in the park in 2009

With no football on the television until August, the only answer was to head over the park, rebuild a famous goal from memory and ask everyone else to name it.

Read on →Mystery Goal No.1: a classic goal recreated in the park in 2009
Articles

A fateful flight: the 1993 Zambia air disaster and the team after it

Thirty people died when the plane taking Zambia to a World Cup qualifier fell into the sea off Libreville. Nineteen years later, Zambia won the Africa Cup of Nations a few miles away.

Read on →A fateful flight: the 1993 Zambia air disaster and the team after it