
Some summers feel like a punishment for loving football. The summer of 2009 was one of them. With no World Cup and no European Championship, the weeks between the end of the season and the August kick-off belonged to other sports, and the BBC gave them every available minute of airtime.
There was the Ashes, which England went on to win at the Oval in August. There was Wimbledon, where Roger Federer beat Andy Roddick 16–14 in a fifth set that seemed to last most of an afternoon. There was the Open at Turnberry, where a 59-year-old Tom Watson came within one putt of the most improbable win in golf before losing a play-off to Stewart Cink. All of it was gripping. None of it was football.
A Saturday without a match
Football supporters deal with the close season in different ways. Some read transfer gossip until their eyes ache. Some watch old videos. A group of friends in the summer of 2009 chose the most traditional option of all: a ball, a park and a pair of jumpers for goalposts, in an attempt to recreate the feeling a Saturday normally brings.
The football itself fell short. There was plenty of effort, and not much talent.
So the plan changed. Instead of trying to play a proper match, the group decided to rebuild their favourite goals, move by move, and bask in a little reflected glory. After many practice runs, and shots that varied wildly in accuracy, they eventually filmed a personal tribute to one classic goal. Skill was in short supply. The celebration made up for it.

Name that goal
The challenge was simple: watch the recreation and work out which famous goal it was. It was billed as an easy one to start the series, with more recreations promised, including one set in an urban location rather than on grass.
Guesses arrived quickly. One suggestion pointed towards Karel Poborský's chip against Portugal at Euro 96, the impossibly high, looping finish at Villa Park that sent the Czech Republic into the semi-finals. It is a goal that every park player has tried at least once, usually with embarrassing results, because the technique only looks simple when someone else does it.
Others were sure they had it but wanted to know whether there was a prize. There was not. The reaction from Paul(No1FaN), who guessed it had taken all day to get right, was closer to the truth than anyone admitted.
Why recreating goals never gets old
Recreating goals is as old as the game. Children in every playground have spent breaktimes pretending to be their heroes, shouting their names as they shoot. In England the most popular choices have been the ones with a memorable celebration attached: Paul Gascoigne's goal against Scotland at Euro 96 and the "dentist's chair" that followed, Roger Milla's dance at the corner flag in 1990, Marco Tardelli's wild-eyed run after scoring in the 1982 World Cup final, or Jürgen Klinsmann's self-mocking dive on his Tottenham debut in 1994.
Those are the goals people remember with their whole body. The run, the arms, the slide on the knees: they are as much a part of the moment as the finish. That explains why an amateur recreation leans on the celebration. The finish might go over the bar on the twelfth attempt, but anyone can copy a dance.
There is also a puzzle element that football supporters cannot resist. Identifying a goal from a few clues is the same instinct behind every pub quiz question about famous strikes, and behind games like guessing the Premier League goalscorer from a looping GIF. Half the fun is the argument about whether the angle was right.
Goals that deserve a second life
For every iconic goal there are dozens that have slipped out of public memory, and recreations are one way of dragging them back. The search for overlooked gems is a theme of the piece on Son Heung-min and the forgotten wonder goals, while the role that grainy tapes played in keeping classic moments alive is the subject of the video age of football.
Recreating a goal is a test of how well it is remembered. A film that gets the angles slightly wrong but nails the celebration says plenty about which part of the moment stays with people.
The series ran to at least four mystery goals before the end of 2009. The first set the tone: a summer park, a borrowed camera, a run of misses and a final, glorious celebration that the original scorer might just have recognised. Fellow football bloggers such as Paul(No1FaN) were among the first to applaud.