
Every football fan knows the feeling. It arrives on a Friday night or a Saturday morning, usually without evidence: today is the day. The striker who has not scored since October will get two. The relegation candidates will hold the leaders. The bad run is about to end.
Sometimes the gut is right. Far more often it is a confident voice talking nonsense, and football has a long list of experts and supporters who trusted instinct over evidence and paid for it.
You can't win anything with kids
The most famous example came on the opening day of the 1995–96 season. Manchester United, having sold Paul Ince, Mark Hughes and Andrei Kanchelskis, lost 3–1 at Aston Villa with a team full of young players. On Match of the Day, Alan Hansen delivered his verdict: you can't win anything with kids.
It was a perfectly reasonable gut reaction. The kids were David Beckham, Gary and Phil Neville, Paul Scholes and Nicky Butt, and United won the league and FA Cup double that season. The line has followed Hansen ever since, and the story is told in full in you never win anything with kids.

Twelve points clear and certain
That same season offered the other side of the coin. Kevin Keegan's Newcastle United were 12 points clear at the top in January 1996, playing thrilling football. Almost everyone's instinct said the title was theirs.
United reeled them in. Keegan's televised outburst in April, ending with the words “I will love it if we beat them, love it”, became one of the defining moments of the decade, and United finished four points clear. The gut feeling of an entire nation had been wrong.
Underdogs nobody saw coming
Tournaments are where instinct suffers most. Denmark did not even qualify for Euro 92, and were called up only after Yugoslavia were excluded. They beat the holders the Netherlands in the semi-final and Germany 2–0 in the final in Gothenburg.
Twelve years later Greece did something similar. Written off before Euro 2004, Otto Rehhagel's side beat the hosts Portugal in the opening game and again in the final in Lisbon, where Angelos Charisteas headed the only goal. Even after a win like that, some neutrals struggled to warm to them, as the question of why nobody adopts Greece as an underdog shows.
The greatest example of all came in 2015–16. Leicester City started that season as 5000/1 outsiders for the Premier League title, having only just escaped relegation the previous spring. Claudio Ranieri's side won the league by ten points. No gut in the country had predicted it.
Why the gut keeps getting it wrong
There are good reasons instinct struggles with football. The sport is low-scoring, so luck plays a bigger part than in most games: a deflection, a post or a refereeing decision can decide a match that one side dominated. Gut feelings ignore that randomness and look for a story instead.
Fans also overrate what happened last week. One good result makes a team feel unstoppable, one bad one makes a manager feel finished. Supporters, understandably, overrate their own team, and pundits are rewarded for bold, quotable calls more than careful ones.
Even the markets get it wrong. In the spring of 2012 United overtook Manchester City in March and went eight points clear in April, yet City still won the title in stoppage time on the final day, a race traced in top tips for the Premier League title. If professional odds-setters can be fooled that often, a Friday-night hunch has very little chance.
None of this will stop anyone. The feeling will arrive again next weekend, as certain as ever, and it will be wrong again roughly as often as it was last time.