Play a quiz
Lower leagues

Home from home at Home Park: Plymouth Argyle’s plan to rebuild

After a decade of debt and near collapse, Plymouth Argyle began the 2013–14 season with a new managing director and a plan built around the city itself.

First published 16 Aug ’13 4 min read Articles →
AIA long old grandstand above a freshly striped pitch near a coastal city (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

The bottom of the League Two table in May 2013 could have served as a case study in what happens to small businesses that fail to adapt when the money runs out. Two of the bottom five were still working from plans drawn up in kinder financial times. Aldershot Town went down with administrators trying to make the sums add up, and AFC Wimbledon kept their heads above water while carrying debts that dated back to buying the lease on Kingsmeadow in 2003.

Plymouth Argyle had suffered more than most, on the pitch and off it, in the years before. They finished 21st that season, but by the following August the club looked as though it was finally laying the foundations of something better.

A new managing director from Yeovil

Martyn Starnes arrived at Home Park that summer from a similar role at Yeovil Town, where he had overseen a rise that took a small club into the Championship. He brought optimism to the Devon coast and talked openly about success, words that had become unfamiliar at Argyle after years of near collapse. “My vision is success and we’ll be looking for (it) early,” he said.

After a decade of crushing debts and speculative spending, Starnes put financial viability and sustainability at the centre of a revised model. With the backing of owner James Brent, plans were in place for a major redevelopment of the club’s facilities, using the local community as the engine for growth.

The logic was geographical. Argyle are one of only three league clubs within a vast stretch of the far south-west, and the support needed to climb the divisions was there in numbers. The challenge was to give those supporters reasons to stay engaged, emotionally and financially, for the long term.

The Pavilions deal and the grandstand plan

A deal with Plymouth City Council to bring the Pavilions leisure site into the ownership of Brent and the Argyle board was meant to act as a springboard, allowing the club to expand its facilities for supporters on matchdays and through the week, subject to final planning permission. Work was expected to begin that autumn.

For long-suffering fans it promised hope not felt since the mid-2000s, when Paul Sturrock’s team rose quickly from the fourth tier and briefly sat at the top of the Championship. Those memories carried a warning. That side’s rise was built on spending the club could not sustain, and the fall that followed took Argyle back down the leagues and close to extinction.

AISupporters in green and white scarves at a matchday bar overlooking a pitch (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

Brent sounded determined when asked about his medium-term plans on BBC Spotlight, with the Championship clearly in his sights. Ambition at Home Park has always been cut from a familiar cloth, and some supporters understandably worried about history repeating itself.

On paper, though, the plans showed an understanding of how a club can work with its community as a whole. The council was well on the way with its multi-million-pound Vision for Plymouth programme, which aimed to bring new life to the local economy and drive up the population through major new housing. Combined, it looked like the basis for a genuinely forward-thinking project in the lower leagues.

What happened next

The patience paid off, slowly. Argyle won promotion to League One in 2017, dropped back two years later and came straight up again in 2020. The redeveloped Mayflower Grandstand gave Home Park a modern main stand, and ownership later passed to Simon Hallett, a long-distance supporter who continued the steady approach. In 2022–23 the club won League One under Steven Schumacher with more than 100 points, reaching the Championship again.

The second tier proved hard to hold, and Argyle were relegated in 2025, but the club that went down was solvent, well supported and owned with care. That contrast with 2013 is the real measure of the change. Plenty of clubs in the Football League have spent beyond their means since the Premier League arrived; Plymouth offered a reminder that a football club can sit at the heart of a local revival instead.

A city club in a remote corner

Home Park itself, a short walk from the city centre beside Central Park, has long been a lonely outpost in English football geography. Away supporters face some of the longest trips in the country, and the cost of following a team that far is considerable, which is part of why Argyle’s own crowds matter so much. Like the intimate lower-league grounds elsewhere, it relies on loyalty more than glamour, and the debate over how money flows between divisions lands harder at clubs that far from the centre.

The story of Argyle’s revival has been told well by independent writers, from a personal blog to fans’ threads on Twitter, and the ground itself has been photographed many times over the years, including the view credited to geograph / Roger Cornfoot.

Questions and answers

Who was Plymouth Argyle's managing director in 2013?

Martyn Starnes, who joined that summer from a similar role at Yeovil Town, where he had overseen a rise into the Championship. With owner James Brent's backing, he put financial viability and sustainability at the centre of the club's plans after a decade of debt.

Where did Plymouth Argyle finish in League Two in 2012–13?

21st, near the bottom of League Two, after years of trouble on the pitch and off it. By the following August the club looked to be laying the foundations for something better, with a new managing director and plans built around the city.

When did Plymouth Argyle get back to the Championship?

In 2022–23, when they won League One under Steven Schumacher with more than 100 points. Before that they were promoted to League One in 2017, dropped back two years later and came straight up again in 2020. They were relegated from the Championship in 2025.

What was the Pavilions deal at Plymouth Argyle?

A deal with Plymouth City Council to bring the Pavilions leisure site into the ownership of James Brent and the Argyle board. It was meant to let the club expand its facilities for supporters on matchdays and through the week, subject to planning permission.

Keep reading

Articles

The intimacy of football at Barnet: a summer afternoon at Underhill

A sloping pitch, a shirt sponsor raffle and every word from the dugout audible: Barnet v Peterborough, July 2010, in front of 547 people.

Read on →The intimacy of football at Barnet: a summer afternoon at Underhill
Articles

Should football clubs be financially rewarded for relegation?

A bigger safety net for relegated clubs was meant to soften the fall. Critics across the Football League feared it would tilt the Championship for good.

Read on →Should football clubs be financially rewarded for relegation?
Articles

The cost of following your team: tickets, travel, pies and pints

Clubs spend in the transfer window; supporters spend all season. A look at what a matchday really costs, and why travelling fans feel it most.

Read on →The cost of following your team: tickets, travel, pies and pints