Play a quiz
Lower leagues

The intimacy of football at Barnet: a summer afternoon at Underhill

A sloping pitch, a shirt sponsor raffle and every word from the dugout audible: Barnet v Peterborough, July 2010, in front of 547 people.

First published 1 Aug ’10 4 min read Articles →
AIA small sloping football ground hemmed in by red-brick terraced houses on a grey day (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

The pitch slopes noticeably towards the South Stand. The club is running a competition to decide who sponsors this season's shirt. The pre-match warm-up looks less like a drill and more like half an hour of friendly kickabout. This was Barnet on the last day of July 2010, hosting Peterborough United in a pre-season friendly at Underhill, and it was a long way from the Premier League in every sense that matters.

The ground sat hemmed in by terraced houses that seemed to tower over it. Stray shots kept disappearing over the stand opposite and into the street behind; one clattered into an upstairs window and dropped into a neighbour's front garden. None of this counted against the afternoon. It was the charm of the thing.

Every shout carries

Stripped of the gloss of the top flight, football at Underhill had an honesty about it that let supporters in on every kick and every tactical tweak from the touchline. A £12 adult ticket bought a seat close enough to hear the players' conversations, and they were not always polite.

In the opening minutes left-back Jordan Parkes could clearly be heard giving centre-back Daniel Leach a considerable earful. Assistant manager Scott Barrett barked instructions throughout, and every one of them reached the stand.

Source: Three Match BanClub flyer inviting supporters to win the Barnet shirt sponsorship through a draw
The 2010 flyer offering one supporter the chance to put a name on the Barnet shirt. · Source: Three Match Ban picture library

Barnet had been here before, in more ways than one. Barry Fry's side reached the Football League for the first time in 1991, the club dropped back into the Conference in 2001, and it took until 2005 to win promotion again. Underhill, with its famous slope and its tight little stands, had been home through all of it, and the people in those stands had seen enough ups and downs not to take a single fixture for granted.

That closeness made for a warm, relaxed crowd. Barnet supporters had reason to be grateful simply to be there: the club had kept its Football League place only on the final day of 2009–10 with a win, and another season of league football felt like a gift rather than an entitlement.

A new manager, fourteen new faces

Peterborough provided a serious test. They had finished 44 places above Barnet in the pyramid the previous season and were now in League One, a division higher. Barnet had a new manager in Mark Stimson and fourteen new signings, brought in to rebuild a depleted squad before the opening league fixture away at Chesterfield on 7 August.

Peterborough had most of the early ball. Barnet worked their way back into it, and after half an hour the effort paid off: a delivery from Parkes on the left fell to Glenn Poole, who finished calmly.

The home crowd liked what it saw, especially the energy of Steve Kabba, a summer arrival from Watford who already looked like a favourite on the terraces. He chased everything. Supporters in the lower divisions tend to forgive a lot in a player who does that.

Source: Three Match BanUnderhill pitch from behind the goal with terraced houses beyond the far end
Underhill before kick-off, with the houses of Barnet looking down on the pitch. · Source: Three Match Ban picture library

A penalty out of nowhere

The game was end to end, never short of energy or commitment. Fans of the lower leagues often claim there is plenty of good football played down there. That is debatable. What is beyond doubt is that plenty of entertaining football is played, and referee Mick Russell seemed keen to contribute. Before the break he gave Peterborough a route back by awarding a penalty when Glen Southam appeared to have headed the ball clear quite legitimately. The home crowd let him know about it. Peterborough captain Grant McCann had no such misgivings and scored from the spot.

Barnet went straight up the other end. Mark Marshall won a penalty of their own, but Joe Lewis, the former England Under-21 goalkeeper, dived low to his right to keep out Poole's kick and deny him a second goal. It stayed 1–1 at half-time.

In the second half the gap between the divisions began to show. Peterborough scored twice in the last ten minutes, both well taken, and won 3–1. Over ninety minutes, McCann, Lewis and company had shown exactly why they were a division higher, even if Barnet had matched them for long spells before the legs started to go.

Why 547 people were enough

The crowd was 547. Against the numbers of the Premier League that is a rounding error, and there was none of the Sky Sports gloss either. It did not matter. Every chant and every heckle reached the players, and the supporters plainly enjoyed it that way.

At a ground like this every fan feels personally tied to what happens on the pitch. They were all there for the same reason, regardless of league position, money worries or the state of the stands: they love the game for what it is, and in the face of plenty of adversity that was a pleasure to see up close.

The rest of the story moved quickly. Peterborough went on to win promotion to the Championship that season through the League One play-offs. Barnet stayed in League Two on the final day once again, then dropped out of the Football League in 2013 and left Underhill for The Hive in Edgware. The sloping pitch is gone, but supporters who stood there still talk about it the way others talk about the welcome at Home Park. For the economics of following a small club, see the cost of following your team, and for the competitive end of non-league survival, the bottom of the FA Cup pile.

Questions and answers

Why was Underhill famous?

Barnet's old ground was known for its pitch, which sloped noticeably towards the South Stand, and for being hemmed in by terraced houses. Stray shots regularly ended up in the street behind. Its tight little stands put fans close enough to hear every word from the players and the dugout.

What was the score when Barnet played Peterborough in July 2010?

Peterborough won the pre-season friendly 3–1 at Underhill on the last day of July 2010, in front of 547 people. Glenn Poole put Barnet ahead, Grant McCann equalised from a disputed penalty, Joe Lewis saved a Barnet penalty, and Peterborough scored twice in the last ten minutes.

When did Barnet leave Underhill?

Barnet dropped out of the Football League in 2013 and left Underhill for The Hive in Edgware. The famous sloping pitch went with the move, though supporters who stood there still talk about it fondly.

When did Barnet first reach the Football League?

Barry Fry's side reached the Football League for the first time in 1991. The club dropped back into the Conference in 2001 and took until 2005 to win promotion again, with Underhill as home through all of it.

Keep reading

Articles

Home from home at Home Park: Plymouth Argyle’s plan to rebuild

After a decade of debt and near collapse, Plymouth Argyle began the 2013–14 season with a new managing director and a plan built around the city itself.

Read on →Home from home at Home Park: Plymouth Argyle’s plan to rebuild
Articles

The road to Wembley or nowhere: the bottom of the FA Cup pile

Haringey Borough 1 AFC Kempston Rovers 3, FA Cup extra preliminary round, August 2012. Fewer than a hundred watched, and every one of them cared.

Read on →The road to Wembley or nowhere: the bottom of the FA Cup pile
Articles

The cost of following your team: tickets, travel, pies and pints

Clubs spend in the transfer window; supporters spend all season. A look at what a matchday really costs, and why travelling fans feel it most.

Read on →The cost of following your team: tickets, travel, pies and pints