Play a quiz
Transfer window

Deadline day disappointment: the January 2010 transfer window

A month of gossip columns ended with a reserve goalkeeper moving to Stoke and a queue of loan deals. A few of them turned out better than they looked.

First published 3 Feb ’10 3 min read Articles →
AICar waiting at a training ground barrier on a rainy winter night (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

Transfer deadline day has a habit of promising fireworks and delivering a damp sparkler. For football supporters the end of January 2010 was a textbook case. A whole month of gossip columns had linked world-class players with every club in the Premier League. When the window finally slammed shut, the headline signing was Asmir Begovic, Portsmouth's reserve goalkeeper, moving to Stoke City for a reported £3.25 million.

Hardly the stuff that sets a fanbase alight.

The loan window

The most striking thing about that January was the method rather than the names. Loans dominated. Club after club sent players out on temporary deals to get first-team football, or brought in short-term cover rather than commit to a permanent fee. It might as well have been renamed the loan window.

There were good reasons. The credit crunch was still biting, several clubs were carrying heavy debts, and January prices are traditionally inflated. It almost looked as if the clubs had quietly agreed not to pay over the odds for players who would be half the price once summer came round.

Manchester United were the exception, as so often. They agreed a deal worth a reported £10m for Fulham's young centre-back Chris Smalling, who stayed at Craven Cottage until the end of the season before moving north. The irony was that United's own finances were under scrutiny at the time, with the borrowing loaded on to the club by the Glazer family a regular subject of protest at Old Trafford.

The football site The Soccer Guys summed up the mood on the day: a boring window, rescued only by one genuinely unexpected move, with debt-ridden clubs simply lacking the cash to splash.

AITelevision and laptop glowing in a dark living room late on a winter night (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

The diamonds in the rough

Amid a lot of very average players moving between very average clubs, a handful of deals stood out.

Eidur Gudjohnsen to Tottenham

Gudjohnsen returned to the Premier League on loan from Monaco, bringing a touch of class and an experienced head to a Tottenham attack chasing a Champions League place. Harry Redknapp's side got there, finishing fourth after Peter Crouch's header won the decisive game at Manchester City in May.

Robbie Keane to Celtic

The surprise of the window was Robbie Keane leaving Spurs for a loan spell at Celtic. Scottish football is often mocked south of the border, but Keane went about his business in Glasgow with real enthusiasm and scored freely, even if the title went to Rangers that season.

Mido to West Ham

The most likeable deal was Mido's return to the Premier League with West Ham, after a spell back in Egypt with Zamalek. He was reportedly paid around £1,000 a week, a remarkably modest sum for a top-flight footballer, which said plenty about how badly he wanted another crack at English football. His weight had been a running story throughout his career, and plenty of neutrals hoped he would finally make it work as a Hammer.

How the deals aged

Hindsight was kinder to that window than the mood on deadline night. Begovic, written off as a reserve, became Stoke's first-choice goalkeeper and later famously scored from his own penalty area against Southampton in November 2013. Smalling went on to win league titles with United and play for England at major tournaments. The Stoke City faithful certainly got their money's worth.

Portsmouth, meanwhile, were weeks away from becoming the first Premier League club to enter administration, which explains why a promising young goalkeeper had to be sold in the first place.

A quieter January, a busier summer

The real spending was being saved. The Soccer Guys predicted an active summer, with Manchester City needing to sort out a bloated squad to suit Roberto Mancini, who had replaced Mark Hughes in December, and they singled out the out-of-favour Stephen Ireland as a player likely to move. They were right. Ireland joined Aston Villa in August 2010 as part of the deal that took James Milner to City, and City's squad clear-out became a story of its own, as covered in the realisation that City had too many players.

Deadline day itself has only grown louder since, with rolling television coverage, reporters outside training grounds and a countdown clock on every screen. The excitement rarely matches the business done. Players who move cheaply often prove the best value of all, as the free transfer XI of summer 2012 showed, and testing how well anyone remembers who went where is half the fun of the transfer history quiz.

January 2010 will never be remembered as a classic window. But it did hand Stoke a goalkeeper whose most famous kick travelled the full length of the pitch.

Keep reading

Articles

A moment of clarity: Manchester City realise they have too many men

After a summer of big signings, Manchester City counted 33 players over 21 just as the Premier League's 25-man squad limit arrived. Somebody had to go, and cheaply.

Read on →A moment of clarity: Manchester City realise they have too many men
Articles

The free transfer XI of summer 2012: Green, Lucio, Drogba, Owen

Eleven players who moved for nothing in the summer of 2012, from Rangers exiles to a Champions League final hero, and what became of them.

Read on →The free transfer XI of summer 2012: Green, Lucio, Drogba, Owen
Quizzes

Guess the player from their transfer history

No faces, no shirts, no goals. Just the clubs, in order, with every loan and homecoming left in. Fifty careers to identify.

Play →Guess the player from their transfer history