
Football changes slowly. Over the last few decades a handful of rules have been tweaked, goalkeepers have lost the right to pick up a back-pass, and three-man defences and mullets have both drifted in and out of fashion. Wages, tactics and the way players approach the game have been transformed, but the basic shape of the big tournaments stayed remarkably stable.
That is why the decision UEFA had already taken by the summer of 2012 felt so significant. While Euro 2012 was still being played in Poland and Ukraine, it was settled that the next European Championship, in France in 2016, would grow from 16 teams to 24.
The biggest change since Euro '92
It was the largest change to the tournament since it doubled from eight teams to sixteen for Euro 96 in England, with Euro '92 in Sweden the last of the eight-team finals. On the surface, more is more. Supporters would get 51 matches instead of the 31 played at Euro 2012, and the bookmakers more football betting opportunities than ever before.
The worry was what it would do to the tournament's status. The European Championship had been the tightest major competition in the game, harder to win in some ways than the World Cup, precisely because there was no room for passengers. Inviting close to half the continent's national teams risked turning an elite event into an extended qualifying campaign.
A maths problem in search of a format
There was also the arithmetic. Twenty-four teams in groups of four, with the top two going through, leaves twelve: too many for a quarter-final and four short of a round of sixteen. One idea floated was four groups of six, which at least made the numbers tidy, but from a viewer's point of view it would have made the group stage feel like a rerun of the two years of qualifying that had just finished.
UEFA's general secretary at the time, Gianni Infantino, admitted the situation was "not ideal". "It is 24 teams and that is a problem," he said. "It is not an ideal final tournament because you will have to have a few of the third ones who qualify as well. The question is how you make it in a way that results cannot be organised and you don't know in advance what you need to be the best." He also promised to look at qualifying so that it would not be "boring". Concerns about integrity had been voiced before a ball was kicked, and the plan went ahead anyway.

Why do it? Follow the money
The reasons were not hard to find. More matches meant more television money, more ticket sales and more space for sponsors, with a bigger slice for UEFA itself. Cynics at the time compared the governing body to the gorging Mr Creosote in Monty Python's The Meaning of Life, forever being offered one more wafer-thin mint.
The loss for neutrals was the group of death. Euro 2012's Group B had included Germany, the Netherlands, Denmark and Portugal, four sides ranked third, fourth, ninth and tenth in FIFA’s world rankings, at the time. With six groups, the strong teams would be spread more thinly, and the prospect was fewer brutal groups and a few more dull ones.
The one obvious upside was for gifted players from smaller football nations, who would finally get a stage. Gareth Bale and Wales were named back then as likely beneficiaries.
How the 24-team Euros turned out
In the end UEFA chose six groups of four, with the four best third-placed teams joining the top two from each group in a round of sixteen. Euro 2016 duly produced some cautious, calculating football as teams played for third place, and Portugal won the whole thing after drawing all three of their group games and squeezing through in third place. They beat France 1–0 after extra time in the final in Saint-Denis.
It also delivered exactly what the optimists had promised. Wales, with Bale, reached the semi-finals, and Iceland knocked England out in the round of sixteen in Nice. The format has stayed ever since, through Euro 2020 and Euro 2024. Infantino, the man who called it "not ideal", became FIFA president in 2016 and has since overseen a 48-team World Cup.
Please gamble responsibly. GambleAware.org 18+