
The 2010 World Cup was weeks away when Fabio Capello named a provisional squad of 30. Most names were expected. One was not. Jamie Carragher, who had walked away from England duty three years earlier, was back.
The obvious question was how he felt about representing his country on the biggest stage in football. Carragher had already answered it, in print. “Representing your country is the ultimate honour, especially in the World Cup. Not to me,” he wrote in his 2008 autobiography.
What Carragher wrote in 2008
That kind of bluntness can be refreshing. Footballers had spent decades repeating that pulling on an England shirt was the proudest moment of their lives, and plenty of supporters found the line hollow. Carragher, to his credit, did not pretend.
He went further than a single sentence. “I confess: defeats wearing an England shirt never hurt me in the same way as losing with my club. I wasn't uncaring or indifferent, I simply didn't put England's fortunes at the top of my priority list. Losing felt like a disappointment rather than a calamity,” he wrote.
The Liver Bird, he explained, “mauled the Three Lions in the fight for my loyalties.” He grew up an Everton fan in Bootle, and the book is clear about where that left 1966: “for my family the most important event at Wembley that year was Everton winning the FA Cup.” Liverpool supporters, he added, remembered that season for Bill Shankly's second league title.
The most quoted passage came from 1986. “When Diego Maradona knocked England out of the 1986 World Cup in Mexico, 10 minutes later I was outside playing with my mates copying the handball goal.” Had it been an Everton defeat in an FA Cup quarter-final, he wrote, he would not have spoken to anyone for the rest of the day. For some, he argued, “civic pride overpowers nationality.”
Why come back in 2010?
None of that is a crime. A player who cares more about his club than his country is being honest, and Merseyside has always had a complicated relationship with the national team. The question in May 2010 was simpler. If England meant so little, why return?
Carragher's own explanation, given to the BBC, was practical. The FA had asked him to reconsider because of injuries in defence, and he agreed. “The World Cup and Champions League are the highest levels of football. I'm not getting any younger, we have no Champions League football (at Liverpool) next season and I am keen to work under Fabio Capello.”
Liverpool had just finished seventh, out of the Champions League places, and Rafael Benitez would be gone within weeks. Read cynically, the route back to the very top level ran through South Africa rather than Anfield. That was the charge at the time: that a player who had openly put England second was returning for the stage rather than the shirt.

The backlash, and the defence
Questioning Carragher's motives provoked a furious response from Liverpool supporters in May 2010, and some of it made good points. He had been the most capped player in England's under-21 history at one stage. He had sat on the bench through squad after squad, and when he did play it was often at right-back rather than in the middle. Earlier approaches from Capello had been turned down, and it took an injury crisis to change his mind. Several fans pointed out that Paul Scholes had also retired from England duty and was rarely accused of anything.
The argument spilled onto phone-ins and message boards, and the tone was rarely gentle. One fan likened a critic of Carragher to a talkSPORT host minus the premium-rate phone lines, and warned that a call would follow before long, pointing to the clip at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTJxocLDfEA by way of explanation.
The criticism was never about his ability. Carragher's commitment for Liverpool was beyond question, and few defenders of his generation gave more in a red shirt. It was about whether a player can say in print that England comes second and then reasonably expect supporters to cheer the U-turn. Nobody got the last word. That jibe, and the link at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTJxocLDfEA that went with it, sums up how quickly a few lines from a book became an argument about loyalty.
How the World Cup went
Carragher made the final 23. He came on against the United States in Rustenburg and started against Algeria in Cape Town, picking up a yellow card in each game, which ruled him out of the 1–0 win over Slovenia. England then lost 4–1 to Germany in Bloemfontein. Carragher retired from international football again after the tournament and played on at Liverpool until 2013, all of his senior career at one club. More on that summer is in the 2010 World Cup section and the wider England coverage, and the bird he chose over the lions sits at the heart of the Liverpool badge.
He went on to become one of the sharpest pundits on Sky Sports. His views on England are still delivered with the same lack of sentiment.