Play a quiz
Football politics

Jack Warner makes Clay Davis look like a saint: FIFA in 2010

Days before the vote for the 2018 World Cup, Panorama turned its cameras on FIFA. The most remarkable figure in the story had survived allegations for decades.

First published 30 Nov ’10 4 min read Articles →
AIEmpty wood-panelled conference hall with a sealed envelope on the long table (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

Three days before FIFA chose the hosts of the 2018 and 2022 World Cups, the BBC's Panorama broadcast an investigation into corruption at the top of world football. In England the reaction was oddly muted on the moral question. The loudest objection was not that the facts were wrong, but that the timing might cost the country its bid, along with the tourism money and the chance to watch a World Cup without a passport.

Whether the programme was unpatriotic or simply journalism doing its job was a matter of opinion. What was much harder to dispute was that FIFA's executive committee contained people with serious questions to answer, and that the most striking of them was Jack Warner.

A survivor at the top table

Fans of The Wire will know Clay Davis, the Baltimore state senator who treats every public office as a revenue stream and greets each new scandal with his drawn-out catchphrase. Next to Warner, he looked like a small-time hustler.

By 2010 the Trinidadian had sat on FIFA's executive committee since 1983 and had been president of CONCACAF, the confederation for North and Central America and the Caribbean, since 1990. In that time he had been accused of exploiting his position again and again, twice by Panorama alone, and he had survived every time. He was also, by then, Trinidad and Tobago's Minister of Works and Transport.

The 2006 tickets

According to the BBC documentary "The Beautiful Bung", FIFA's auditors Ernst & Young estimated that Warner's family had made a profit of at least $1 million from reselling 2006 World Cup tickets that he had ordered. Minutes of FIFA's executive committee indicated that a fine of almost $1 million, roughly equal to the profit, was imposed on the family. The Daily Mail later alleged that only around $250,000 had been paid despite repeated reminders.

It did not appear to deter anyone. Panorama said it had seen e-mails and an invoice showing Warner was involved in procuring $84,000 worth of tickets for the 2010 World Cup in South Africa, apparently destined for the black market. The deal, which included 38 tickets for the final in Johannesburg, fell through only because the touts would not meet the asking price.

The contrast with Robbie Earle was hard to miss. The former Wimbledon midfielder lost his job as an ITV pundit during that same 2010 World Cup after tickets allocated to him ended up being used in a brewery's ambush-marketing stunt, a story covered in ITV's decision to drop Robbie Earle. He was out within days. Warner kept his seat.

AIStack of blank tickets with a paper clip beside a phone under a lamp (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

The Soca Warriors' bonus

Further allegations followed Trinidad and Tobago's first World Cup appearance, in Germany in 2006, when Warner was acting as a special adviser to the national federation. He was said to have brokered an agreement under which the players would share the proceeds of their participation.

After the tournament the federation declared revenue of TT$18.25 million and costs of TT$17.9 million, and offered each player TT$5,644.08. The squad rejected the figure and disputed the accounts, with some justification: those declared expenses amounted to well over a million pounds. The Trinidad and Tobago government later revealed that the federation had received more than TT$173 million for its part in the tournament.

The dispute went to the UK's Sports Dispute Resolution Panel. The arbitrator, Ian Mill QC, ruled that the players were entitled to 50 per cent of the World Cup participation money and of commercial revenues linked to qualification, plus half the net income from warm-up matches. Yet the Trinidad Express quoted the players' lawyer, Michael Townley, saying that "at the moment, the players have not received a single cent", and alleging the federation had defaulted on its payment to the arbitration body.

Then there was the story, reported by the Sunday Herald, that after Trinidad and Tobago played Scotland in a friendly in 2004 Warner asked Scottish FA president John McBeth for a cheque made out to him personally rather than to the federation.

What happened after the vote

On 2 December 2010 England's 2018 bid received just two votes and went out in the first round. Russia won the 2018 vote and Qatar the 2022 contest.

Warner's untouchable status did not last much longer. In 2011 he was caught up in the cash-for-votes affair around Mohammed bin Hammam's challenge for the FIFA presidency and resigned from all his football positions before an ethics investigation could conclude. In May 2015 he was among the officials indicted by the United States Department of Justice in the sweeping FIFA corruption case, and later that year FIFA's ethics committee banned him from football for life. He then spent years fighting extradition from Trinidad.

The players' complaint, over a few thousand Trinidadian dollars each, had pointed in the same direction years before the American prosecutors arrived. Clay Davis would have recognised every move.

Questions and answers

Who is Jack Warner?

A Trinidadian football administrator who sat on FIFA's executive committee from 1983 and was president of CONCACAF, the confederation for North and Central America and the Caribbean, from 1990. By 2010 he was also Trinidad and Tobago's Minister of Works and Transport.

What did Panorama allege about Jack Warner and World Cup tickets?

The BBC programme reported that FIFA's auditors estimated Warner's family made at least $1 million reselling 2006 World Cup tickets he had ordered. It also said it had seen e-mails and an invoice linking him to $84,000 of tickets for the 2010 tournament, apparently destined for the black market.

Why did the Trinidad and Tobago players dispute their 2006 World Cup bonus?

After the tournament the federation offered each player TT$5,644.08, which the squad rejected. An arbitrator, Ian Mill QC, later ruled they were entitled to half of the World Cup participation money and related commercial revenue, yet their lawyer said they had not received a single cent.

What happened to Jack Warner after the 2018 World Cup vote?

He resigned all his football positions in 2011 amid the cash-for-votes affair around Mohammed bin Hammam's FIFA presidency bid. In May 2015 he was indicted by the US Department of Justice in the FIFA corruption case, FIFA's ethics committee banned him for life later that year, and he spent years fighting extradition.

Keep reading

Articles

ITV sack Robbie Earle: the 2010 World Cup ticket affair

A group in orange dresses, a brewery stunt and a pundit's ticket allocation. How one of ITV's World Cup voices lost his seat in South Africa, and what the studio sounded like without him.

Read on →ITV sack Robbie Earle: the 2010 World Cup ticket affair
Articles

The end of the 16-team Euros and the move to 24 teams

As Euro 2012 reached its climax, UEFA was already planning a bigger, baggier tournament for France. The fears of the time, and what came of them.

Read on →The end of the 16-team Euros and the move to 24 teams
Articles

Poland v Lithuania tensions at Lech Poznan, and UEFA's empty fine

A 50-foot banner, a token punishment and a campaign that started online. The 2013 Europa League tie that showed where real change comes from.

Read on →Poland v Lithuania tensions at Lech Poznan, and UEFA's empty fine