Play a quiz
World Cup 2010

England stumble and the press pounce after USA 1–1 England

One fumble in Rustenburg handed the tabloids an easy night's work. What they could not agree on was whether England were doomed or still bringing the Cup home.

First published 14 Jun ’10 3 min read Articles →
AIFolded Sunday newspapers and a cup of tea on a newsagent's counter with bunting (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

The English press has two great loves, scandal and failure, and on Saturday 12 June 2010 the national team handed it the second on a plate. England drew 1–1 with the United States in Rustenburg in their opening match of the World Cup in South Africa, and the goal that let the Americans back in was the kind newspapers dream about.

Steven Gerrard had put England ahead in the fourth minute. Shortly before half-time, Clint Dempsey hit a speculative shot from outside the area, straight at Robert Green. The West Ham goalkeeper went down, the ball squirmed through his hands, and he scrambled back in vain as it rolled into the net. By Sunday morning that image was on the front and back pages of almost every paper in the country.

A fall guy, but no agreed verdict

Usually the tabloids settle quickly on a scapegoat, as if by collective agreement, and the nation is given someone to blame. This time the target was obvious. The verdict was not. The red tops condemned with great hyperbole, but without a shared opinion on what the result actually meant.

The Daily Star went on the attack, with a back-page headline that read “ROB-BISH! Clown Green drops us in brown stuff”. The Sun chose to give up on the whole tournament at the first hurdle:

“NEW boss, new hope, nice new shirts for a fresh adventure as the World Cup breaks new ground. But the same old England… It never takes them long to bring their fans back down to earth and leave them wondering why they were deluded enough to believe they could actually win this thing.”

The Daily Star argues with itself

The uncertainty was captured best by the Star. Having declared on the back page that Green's slippery grip had left England knee-deep in trouble, the paper might have been expected to carry the same message on the front. It did not. Apparently the news and sport desks had not compared notes, because the front page ran with the cheerful “DON'T PANIC. We WILL still bring Cup home”.

So England were simultaneously finished and about to win the World Cup, depending on which side of the paper a reader started from.

The contradiction did not go unnoticed. One reader, Dean @ Footballgambler Blog , wrote that the inconsistency between the Star's front and back pages summed up the tabloids, and that the headlines had gone totally over the top for what was, in fairness, a massive blunder.

AIPub crowd seen from behind with hands on heads watching a blurred television (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

The broadsheets and the bigger problem

The broadsheets kept more perspective and far less sensationalism, but the tone was one of subdued embarrassment. Most of the analysis focused on Fabio Capello's decision to start Green ahead of David James and Joe Hart, which conveniently moved attention away from the fact that England had drawn with a limited United States side.

The performance itself got off lightly. England had been stunted and uninspiring, and that was thrown into sharp relief on Sunday evening when Germany took Australia apart 4–0 in Durban with a young, fluid side. Squad selection was another worry. Writing the same week, Dean @ Footballgambler Blog questioned why Capello had packed the squad with defenders, wondered why Matthew Upson had been taken at all if he was not going to play, and predicted that the return of Gareth Barry from injury would restore the system the players knew.

The squad had already caused debate before a ball was kicked, with Theo Walcott left out altogether, a decision covered in a look at whether his replacement was any better. More from that summer sits under World Cup 2010 and the wider England section.

Next game, innit

There was an air of indifference about the result too. It was only the first game, and with Algeria and Slovenia still to come, better results against them than the Americans managed would still send England through as group winners.

That shrug was best captured by Dizzee Rascal, a guest on James Corden's late-night ITV World Cup show. Asked how he felt after the match, he replied: “I was on the edge of my seat all game… I thought we had ’em… I thought we had ’em… but next game innit.” Onwards and upwards, more or less.

It did not work out that way. Green never played again at the tournament, with James taking over for a dreary 0–0 draw against Algeria in Cape Town. Jermain Defoe's goal beat Slovenia 1–0, but Landon Donovan's stoppage-time winner against Algeria meant the United States topped the group, and England were sent into a last-16 tie with Germany in Bloemfontein. They lost 4–1. Upson, the defender whose place had been questioned, scored England's goal, and Frank Lampard had a shot bounce well over the line without a goal being given, a moment that did more than any fumble to bring goal-line technology into the game.

Please gamble responsibly. GambleAware.org 18+

Questions and answers

What happened when England played the USA at the 2010 World Cup?

England drew 1–1 in Rustenburg on 12 June 2010. Steven Gerrard scored in the fourth minute, but shortly before half-time a speculative shot from Clint Dempsey squirmed through Robert Green's hands and into the net.

How did the newspapers react to Robert Green's mistake?

The tabloids blamed Green but could not agree on what it meant. The Daily Star managed both views at once, with a back page mocking Green and a front page insisting England would still bring the Cup home. The broadsheets were calmer and focused on Capello's choice of goalkeeper.

Did Robert Green play again at the 2010 World Cup?

No. David James took over for the dreary 0–0 draw with Algeria in Cape Town and kept his place for the rest of England's tournament, which included a 1–0 win over Slovenia and the 4–1 defeat by Germany.

How did England go out of the 2010 World Cup?

Landon Donovan's late winner against Algeria meant the United States topped the group, so England met Germany in the last 16 in Bloemfontein. They lost 4–1. Matthew Upson scored England's goal, and Frank Lampard had a shot bounce over the line without a goal being given.

Keep reading

Topics

World Cup 2010: vuvuzelas, Iniesta's winner and Bloemfontein

Africa's first World Cup gave the world a new champion, a disallowed goal that changed the rules and a quarter-final nobody in Accra will forget.

Read on →World Cup 2010: vuvuzelas, Iniesta's winner and Bloemfontein
Articles

Trust your gut? Football predictions that went badly wrong

Every fan has a feeling about the weekend. History suggests the feeling is usually wrong, and the more confident it is, the more wrong it tends to be.

Read on →Trust your gut? Football predictions that went badly wrong
Articles

Walcott left out of England's 2010 squad: was his replacement better?

On 1 June 2010 Fabio Capello named his 23 for South Africa. The absence of Theo Walcott took the headlines, though the real question was who went instead.

Read on →Walcott left out of England's 2010 squad: was his replacement better?