Play a quiz
Transfer sagas

Wayne Rooney leaving Manchester United for City? The tabloids said so

For a few days in October 2010 the papers spoke for Wayne Rooney, and the story they told had him crossing Manchester. The ending was rather different.

First published 19 Oct ’10Revised Oct ’26 3 min read Articles →
AIHand reaching for a folded newspaper on a rainy newsagent's counter (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

In the middle of October 2010 Wayne Rooney, Manchester United's best player, did not appear to need to say anything at all. The tabloids were doing the talking for him, and according to them he was finished at Old Trafford and on his way across the city to Manchester City, the newly rich neighbours who had been buying their way towards the top since the takeover by Sheikh Mansour in 2008.

It was a story built for the front and back pages. United's most famous homegrown star of the era, the boy from Everton who had scored on his Champions League debut with a hat-trick against Fenerbahçe, defecting to the club United fans had spent decades mocking. For a few days it seemed entirely possible.

A week of statements

The facts that did emerge were dramatic enough. On 19 October Sir Alex Ferguson confirmed that Rooney had asked to leave, saying he was "dumbfounded" by the decision. The following day Rooney issued a statement saying he had been unable to get assurances about the future make-up of the squad and questioning whether the club could keep attracting the best players.

Coming from a player who had won three league titles and the Champions League with United, it was an extraordinary public challenge to the club's ambition. It was also, as several observers pointed out at the time, the language of a contract negotiation as much as a farewell.

AIReporters with cameras waiting under umbrellas outside closed training ground gates (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

Negotiation, not departure

That reading proved correct. One supporter summed up the sceptical view well: this was all negotiation tactics to secure a better contract, a dangerous game to play with Ferguson in charge, and the chance of Rooney actually leaving was slim. Few people talking about a move to City had stopped to consider how unlikely United were to sell their star striker to their closest rivals, whatever the price.

On 22 October, three days after Ferguson's press conference, Rooney signed a new five-year contract. Within a week of the "he's going to City" headlines he had committed his peak years to United, and the tabloid ventriloquism had told readers more about the appetite for a transfer saga than about Rooney's intentions.

What happened next

The episode left a mark with some supporters, but the football soon smoothed things over. In February 2011 Rooney scored the overhead kick against City at Old Trafford that is still regarded as one of the greatest goals in Premier League history, the perfect reply to anybody who had pictured him in sky blue. United won the league that season, and again in 2012–13.

He would flirt with leaving again in 2013, when Chelsea made bids under José Mourinho, and stayed once more. In January 2017 his free kick at Stoke City made him United's all-time leading scorer, passing the record of Sir Bobby Charlton, and he finished with 253 goals for the club.

Rooney's eventual departure from United, in the summer of 2017, took him back to Everton rather than to City. He later played for DC United in Major League Soccer and for Derby County before moving into management, a career that took him to Derby, DC United, Birmingham City and Plymouth Argyle.

The derby that never was

A Rooney transfer to City would have been the most explosive move between the two clubs since Denis Law and Carlos Tevez. It is not hard to see why the papers wanted it so badly: the Manchester derby was becoming a genuine title fight, and a switch of allegiance would have poured petrol on it. The punning headlines of the day, from the "blue Roon" week in headlines onwards, show how much fun Fleet Street had with the idea.

Rooney had already learned how the tabloids could shape a narrative around him, as the contrasting coverage of his private life and David Beckham's had shown. In October 2010 they went one better and announced his career plans for him. They got the city right and the club wrong.

Questions and answers

Did Wayne Rooney ever sign for Manchester City?

No. Despite a week of October 2010 headlines placing him in sky blue, Rooney signed a new five-year contract with Manchester United on 22 October 2010. When he did leave Old Trafford in the summer of 2017, he went back to his boyhood club Everton rather than across Manchester.

Why did Rooney say he wanted to leave Manchester United in 2010?

In a statement on 20 October 2010 he said he had been unable to get assurances about the future make-up of the squad and questioned whether the club could keep attracting the best players. Many observers read it as the language of a contract negotiation rather than a farewell, and so it proved.

How did Sir Alex Ferguson react to Rooney's transfer request?

Ferguson confirmed at a press conference on 19 October 2010 that Rooney had asked to leave and said he was dumbfounded by the decision. Three days later the striker had committed his peak years to United on a new five-year deal.

How many goals did Wayne Rooney score for Manchester United?

He scored 253 goals for the club. His free kick at Stoke City in January 2017 took him past Sir Bobby Charlton's record to become United's all-time leading scorer, and a month after the City saga, in February 2011, he scored his famous overhead kick against them at Old Trafford.

Keep reading

Week in headlines

Week in headlines: Liverpool's red flops and Wayne, a blue Roon?

October 2010: the biggest club in Merseyside history sat in the relegation zone and the best player in England said he wanted to leave Old Trafford.

Read on →Week in headlines: Liverpool's red flops and Wayne, a blue Roon?
Articles

The Manchester derby in statistics: cold hard facts of City v United

Before the FA Cup semi-final of April 2011, a derby preview in numbers: head-to-head records, cup meetings, record wins, top scorers and one very tough goalkeeper.

Read on →The Manchester derby in statistics: cold hard facts of City v United
Articles

Wayne Rooney and David Beckham: different reactions to tabloid claims

Two of England’s most famous footballers, two sets of claims about their private lives and two very different responses from the public and the papers.

Read on →Wayne Rooney and David Beckham: different reactions to tabloid claims