
Every football fan has done it. A new signing appears in his first press conference, or a manager stands on the touchline in a long coat, and somebody in the pub says it out loud: he looks exactly like someone. Within minutes the comparison has spread across the bar, and within a week it may have become a terrace song.
Lookalikes are one of football’s oldest and most harmless pastimes, and they deserve a closer look.
Where the habit comes from
The tradition owes a lot to print. For decades newspapers and magazines ran features placing two photographs side by side, a famous face from one walk of life beside a famous face from another, and inviting readers to note the resemblance. The satirical magazine Private Eye has run a long-standing lookalikes column built on exactly that idea, and footballers and managers have featured regularly.
Football fanzines took the idea and ran with it. In the late 1980s and 1990s, when supporters produced their own magazines on photocopiers and sold them outside grounds, a lookalikes page was a familiar feature. Readers sent in suggestions, the editors chose the best, and the results ranged from uncanny to wonderfully tenuous.
Part of the appeal was simply that football produced so many recognisable faces at a time when television coverage was limited. Sticker albums and team photos meant fans studied players’ faces closely, which made the comparisons sharper.
The rules of a good lookalike
The best comparisons have a few things in common.
- They are surprising. A footballer who resembles another footballer is mildly interesting; a footballer who resembles a newsreader, a cartoon character or a period drama actor is much better.
- They are about a whole look, not a single feature. Hairstyle, expression, posture and even the way someone stands on the touchline all count.
- They are affectionate. The point is a shared smile, not cruelty about how someone looks.
That last rule matters. Comparing a midfielder’s magnificent perm to a 1980s pop star’s is a celebration of an era; mocking a player’s appearance is something else entirely, and the best lookalike features have always known the difference.

Hairstyles, eras and the camera
Many of the most famous lookalikes come from particular decades. The 1970s and 1980s produced extravagant hairstyles, sideburns and moustaches that made players look like the actors, musicians and television presenters of the same era, simply because everyone was following the same fashions. A team photo from 1985 can look remarkably like the cast of a television drama from the same year.
That is why so much lookalike humour overlaps with the joy of old kits and old stickers. The top ten of football facial hair and the facially fuzzy player sticker quiz are both, in a sense, celebrations of the same thing: the distinctive look of footballers in a particular time.
Some players become associated with a comparison for their whole careers. Supporters chant it, opposition fans adopt it, and occasionally the player himself joins in, posing for a photograph alongside his supposed double. Others are less amused, which is fair enough.
Lookalikes in the modern game
Social media has turned the old fanzine feature into a daily event. Side-by-side images now spread around the world within minutes of a match, and broadcasters and clubs themselves sometimes join in. Professional lookalikes of famous footballers have even built careers appearing at events and in advertisements, a sign of how recognisable the biggest stars have become.
What has not changed is the basic pleasure: spotting a resemblance nobody else has noticed and sharing it with friends. It is the same instinct that keeps fans studying old photographs, such as the pictorial study of Carlton Palmer, long after the matches themselves have been forgotten.
The rule for this series is simple. Comparisons stay friendly, nobody is mocked for how they look, and the reader is always free to disagree. Part one opens the album. The doubles are out there, standing on touchlines, sitting in dugouts and lining up for team photographs, waiting to be noticed.