Play a quiz
Managers

A managerial dismissal at Reading can be justified, with a plan

Brian McDermott took Reading up as champions and was sacked ten months later. The timing, and the lack of a replacement, made a hard call look reckless.

First published 14 Mar ’13Revised Oct ’26 3 min read Articles →
AIEmpty technical area with a coat left on the bench in a floodlit modern stadium (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

Managers can be shown the door at any moment by an ambitious chairman, even if they exceeded every expectation only a season earlier. In March 2013 Brian McDermott became the latest to learn that lesson.

McDermott had guided Reading to the Premier League as champions of the Championship in 2011–12. Ten months later, with the club in the relegation zone but still within reach of safety thanks largely to the team spirit he had built, he was handed his P45 and left to reflect on the futility of his efforts.

The Southampton comparison

The obvious parallel was Nigel Adkins. In January 2013 Southampton dismissed the manager who had taken them from League One to the Premier League in successive seasons. Sackings of managers whose achievements fall short of a chairman's ambition are so common that the next casualty has become a regular feature of English football predictions.

The Southampton decision looked cruel at the time. The Saints chairman, Nicola Cortese, chose to sack Adkins, even though the side had lost only twice in 12 league games before his departure. Supporters were furious and much of the press was baffled.

What Southampton did have was a plan. Mauricio Pochettino was appointed on the same day, giving the club a new head coach immediately and allowing the players to resume the task of staying in the financially precious top flight without losing a week. Southampton went on to survive comfortably that season, and Pochettino's high-pressing side laid the foundations for the club's best years in the Premier League before he left for Tottenham in 2014.

AICardboard box of belongings with a whistle and stopwatch in a bare club office (picture made with AI)
Packing up: the routine end of a modern managerial reign. · Picture made with AI · About our images

Reading's empty dugout

Reading did not follow that model. The club's academy manager, Eamonn Dolan, was placed in temporary charge for the trip to Manchester United that weekend, leaving the players with an interim boss and no clear direction for the nine crucial games that remained.

The owner, Anton Zingarevich, described the dismissal as the “hardest decision of his life” on the Wednesday after it was made. Having identified what he saw as the cause of Reading's troubles, though, he and the board struggled to find a quick solution, stranding the club in an unnecessary period of transition at the worst possible moment.

Timing is everything in these decisions. Had the change been made two months earlier, in January, a new manager would have had the transfer window to strengthen the squad with some of the owner's money and the weeks needed to impose his authority. In mid-March, with the window shut, none of that was possible.

A warning from Wolverhampton

The horse had bolted. Reading faced a relegation fight without a leader, and the men upstairs needed to persuade someone to take on a near-impossible task before the situation drifted towards the kind of farce seen at Wolves. There, Mick McCarthy was sacked in February 2012 and replaced by his assistant, Terry Connor, who could not prevent relegation; his successor, Ståle Solbakken, lasted only until January 2013, and the club slid towards a second successive relegation under Dean Saunders. Chaotic changes of that kind are catalogued in 20 changes of management in 10 chaotic Championship months.

If Zingarevich had taken Southampton as his model, he had acted too late, and without the forethought to have a replacement ready.

What followed

The irony arrived quickly. On 26 March Reading appointed Nigel Adkins, the very manager Southampton had dismissed two months earlier. He had eight games to save the club, and it was not enough. Reading's relegation was confirmed in April after a goalless draw with Queens Park Rangers, a result that sent both clubs down together.

McDermott's reputation survived the sacking. He later managed Leeds United and returned to Reading for a second spell, proof that the qualities which won the Championship in 2012 had not vanished in the space of ten months.

Both owners blamed the manager for their club's problems. Only one of them had someone ready to take over the next morning. Unless the Reading decision was taken in a fit of impatience, it was a careless and cavalier one, and its cost was measured in a league table. For another angle on what relegation is worth to a club's finances, see whether clubs should be rewarded for going down; for the club that got the timing right, the Southampton badge story charts the Saints through the decades.

Please gamble responsibly. GambleAware.org 18+

Questions and answers

Why was Brian McDermott sacked by Reading?

McDermott led Reading to the Premier League as Championship winners in 2011–12, but ten months later, in March 2013, the club were in the relegation zone and owner Anton Zingarevich dismissed him, calling it the hardest decision of his life. The club had no replacement ready, which made the move look reckless.

Who replaced Brian McDermott at Reading?

Academy manager Eamonn Dolan took temporary charge first. On 26 March 2013 Reading appointed Nigel Adkins, the manager Southampton had dismissed two months earlier. He had eight games to keep the club up, and it was not enough.

When were Reading relegated from the Premier League in 2013?

Reading's relegation was confirmed in April 2013 after a goalless draw with Queens Park Rangers, a result that sent both clubs down together. It came only a season after Reading had won the Championship under Brian McDermott.

Why did Southampton's sacking of Nigel Adkins work out better?

Southampton dismissed Adkins in January 2013 but appointed Mauricio Pochettino on the same day, so the players lost no time. The club survived comfortably that season, and Pochettino's high-pressing side laid the foundations for Southampton's best Premier League years before he left for Tottenham in 2014.

Keep reading

Articles

The fortnightly change: 20 managers gone in 10 Championship months

Blackburn had four bosses, Wolves paid off two and Nottingham Forest went full circle. The 2012–13 Championship season was a carousel.

Read on →The fortnightly change: 20 managers gone in 10 Championship months
Articles

Should football clubs be financially rewarded for relegation?

A bigger safety net for relegated clubs was meant to soften the fall. Critics across the Football League feared it would tilt the Championship for good.

Read on →Should football clubs be financially rewarded for relegation?
Club badges

Southampton badge history: halo, tree and a crest by supporters

A halo for St Mary's, a tree for the New Forest, water for the docks and a white rose for Hampshire. The Saints crest has barely changed in more than fifty years.

Read on →Southampton badge history: halo, tree and a crest by supporters