Play a quiz
Copa America

Copa America 2011, part four: over-achievers Paraguay and Ecuador

Two smaller nations that had punched far above their weight in the 2000s. A preview of Paraguay and Ecuador in Argentina, and the remarkable route one of them took to the final.

First published 20 Jun ’11 6 min read Articles →
AIGoalkeeper crouched on the line during a night-time penalty shoot-out, seen from behind (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

Paraguay went into the 2011 Copa America with genuine hopes of winning it. That alone was a measure of how far the country had come. Ecuador, their group rivals, arrived in a very different frame of mind, with a golden generation breaking up and a new coach still finding his feet. Both had spent the previous decade over-achieving.

Paraguay: small nation, big reputation

Raising Paraguay to its position as one of the top four sides in South America had been an achievement in itself. The country is small, with a modest population, landlocked between Bolivia, Brazil and Argentina. Its football has always prided itself on toughness and on overcoming difficult odds.

They had done exactly that. After appearing in Mexico in 1986, Paraguay went on to qualify for four successive World Cups from 1998 to 2010, and made the quarter-finals for the first time in South Africa. Success in the Copa America was more distant, with titles in 1953 and 1979. This generation, though, much of it together under the coach Gerardo Martino since 2007 and perhaps playing its last tournament together in Argentina, had the quality and experience to beat any of its continental rivals.

They had a habit of upsetting the bigger nations, beating both Brazil and Argentina at home during qualifying for South Africa. The World Cup confirmed how hard they were to beat: a draw with holders Italy, a goalless last-16 tie with Japan won on penalties, and a 1–0 defeat by Spain, the eventual champions, in the quarter-final.

The weakness was goals, and it had a painful cause. Salvador Cabañas, the stocky, skilful Club América striker who had been their best player, had not played since he was shot in the head in a bar in Mexico City in January 2010. He survived, and his recovery was remarkable, but the team never truly replaced him.

Predicting their form was also difficult. Paraguay were notoriously poor in friendlies and needed the heat of competition to play to their potential, which meant warm-up results told observers very little.

AIGrown men in striped shirts playing on a red-earth pitch at sunset beside palm trees (picture made with AI)
A small, landlocked nation with an outsized football reputation. · Picture made with AI · About our images

Martino's midfield and an ageing defence

Martino, an Argentine, was a protégé of Marcelo Bielsa, having captained the Newell's Old Boys side Bielsa coached, and he shared some of his mentor's gifts without slavishly copying him. He liked a 4-3-3 but adapted it to the opposition. Much of Paraguay's strength lay in a solid midfield of all-rounders: Enrique Vera of LDU Quito, Atalanta's Edgar Barreto and Víctor Cáceres of Libertad, who screened the defence and supported the forwards. Cáceres, a calm and disciplined fulcrum, may have been the most important of all, but an injury in a recent friendly threatened his participation. If he missed out, the choice lay between Olimpia's Osmar Molinas, a disciplined holding player, and Monterrey's Osvaldo Martínez, a more attacking midfielder who could also play off the strikers.

Behind them was an ageing but still impressive back line. Wigan's Antolín Alcaraz, Libertad's Carlos Bonet, Paulo da Silva, the former Sunderland defender then at Zaragoza, and Pumas' Darío Verón were all in their thirties, and the 2014 World Cup in Brazil looked like one tournament too far for most of them. For now they remained stubborn and disciplined, short only of a natural right-back.

Up front, the obvious successor to Cabañas was the Argentine-born Lucas Barrios, who had just completed a superb season at Borussia Dortmund, scoring heavily as Jürgen Klopp's young side won the Bundesliga. He was likely to be part of a front three with Roque Santa Cruz, who said this would be his final tournament. At 29, and plagued by injuries, "Rocky" was still a potent weapon when fit: dominant in the air, tidy on the ground, able to score and to link play.

European observers might have been surprised by the absence of Benfica's Óscar Cardozo. Prolific in Portugal, he had never convinced for his country, with five goals in 37 games, and Paraguayan supporters were less dazzled by European success than outsiders might assume, so his omission barely registered. Competing for the other attacking place were Pachuca's Édgar Benítez and Hércules' Nelson Haedo Valdez, both comfortable on the flank, and Valdez, strong in the air, had formed a formidable partnership with Santa Cruz in a recent friendly against Bolivia.

Group B, with Venezuela, Ecuador and Brazil, looked manageable. Paraguay could approach every game without fear, and with the format sending eight of the twelve teams into the quarter-finals, even second or third place would leave them three wins from the trophy.

AIHigh-altitude stadium beneath green mountains with a crowd mostly dressed in yellow (picture made with AI)
Home games at altitude helped transform a nation's World Cup record. · Picture made with AI · About our images

Ecuador: the end of a golden generation

Ecuador were in a tricky transitional phase. The golden generation that had taken them to the World Cups of 2002 and 2006, reaching the last 16 in Germany, was breaking up, and there seemed to be no equally talented young players ready to take over.

Their rise had been remarkable: before 2002 they had never qualified for a World Cup at all. Their Copa America record remained poor, though. Even during their best years they rarely went beyond the group stage.

Part of the explanation was a change in CONMEBOL's qualifying system. From the 1998 World Cup, every South American nation played every other home and away in a single marathon group, which suited Ecuador perfectly given how fearsome they were at altitude in Quito. That coincided with the emergence of a group of players led by the centre-forward Agustín Delgado and a strong defence built around Iván Hurtado, and with a series of Colombian coaches who brought tactical nous from their own football culture and married it to Ecuadorian speed and strength.

By 2011 Delgado and Hurtado had retired, and their replacements were not of the same calibre. Almost the entire defence played for one of the two Quito giants, LDU or Deportivo, the exception being the captain, Walter Ayoví of Monterrey, a marauding wing-back with a taste for long-range shooting and the only truly outstanding player in the back line.

Benítez, Caicedo and Valencia

The two likely starting forwards were familiar to English audiences. Christian "Chucho" Benítez had spent a season on loan at Birmingham City from Santos Laguna, and Felipe Caicedo, still on Manchester City's books, had enjoyed a productive loan at Levante. Caicedo had been the wonder boy of Ecuadorian football and had not quite fulfilled that early billing, though his recent form was encouraging. Benítez was a big-game player for his country, a creator and finisher who worked tirelessly, with 15 goals in 36 internationals at the time. Caicedo's Levante team-mate Jefferson Montero was the best option from the bench, with Jaime Ayoví as plan B.

The coach, Reinaldo Rueda, another Colombian, had done well to take Honduras to the 2010 World Cup. He usually favoured a 4-4-2, with creativity from the wings through Manchester United's Antonio Valencia and Michael Arroyo of San Luis, and solidity in the centre from Segundo Castillo alongside the passing of Christian Noboa. Midfield was the team's strongest area, which kept their matches tight, though defensive frailties had cost them recently. The tournament looked like a rehearsal for qualifying for 2014, by which time Rueda would be settled and some of his younger players would have grown into the side.

AIWorn football resting on the penalty spot of a floodlit pitch at night (picture made with AI)
Paraguay reached the 2011 final without winning a single match in normal time. · Picture made with AI · About our images

What happened in Argentina

Paraguay's tournament was one of the strangest in the history of the competition. They drew all three group games, 0–0 with Ecuador, 2–2 with Brazil and 3–3 with Venezuela, and squeezed through as a third-placed team. In the quarter-final they held Brazil to a goalless draw and won the shoot-out after the Brazilians missed every one of their penalties. In the semi-final against Venezuela it was 0–0 again, and Paraguay won on penalties once more.

So they reached the final without winning a match in normal time. There the run ended: Uruguay beat them 3–0 in Buenos Aires, Luis Suárez scoring once and Diego Forlán twice, to take a record 15th Copa America title. The Uruguayan side and their rivals Chile are previewed in part five of the guide, and an earlier Uruguayan triumph can be relived in the 1995 Copa America final.

Ecuador went out in the group, beaten by Venezuela and Brazil. Rueda's long-term plan worked, however: Ecuador qualified for the 2014 World Cup in Brazil. Benítez was not there to see it. He died suddenly in July 2013, aged just 27, while playing in Qatar, a loss felt deeply across Ecuadorian football.

Martino's career took off after 2011. He went on to coach Barcelona, Argentina, Atlanta United, whom he led to the MLS Cup, and Mexico. The guide's other instalments include the guest nations, Mexico and Costa Rica. More South American football writing from the author of this guide can be found at GolGolGolGolGol and on his Twitter page.

Brazil's four missed penalties in La Plata remain one of the most extraordinary shoot-outs any major tournament has produced.

Questions and answers

How did Paraguay reach the 2011 Copa America final without winning a game?

Paraguay drew all three group games, with Ecuador, Brazil and Venezuela, and went through as a third-placed side. They then beat Brazil and Venezuela on penalties after goalless draws, reaching the final without a single win in normal time before losing 3–0 to Uruguay.

Who was Paraguay's coach at the 2011 Copa America?

Gerardo Martino, an Argentine and a protégé of Marcelo Bielsa, who had captained Bielsa's Newell's Old Boys. In charge since 2007, he went on to coach Barcelona, Argentina, Atlanta United, whom he led to the MLS Cup, and Mexico.

What happened to Salvador Cabañas?

Cabañas, the Club América striker who had been Paraguay's best player, was shot in the head in a bar in Mexico City in January 2010. He survived and made a remarkable recovery, but he never played for Paraguay again and the side struggled for goals without him.

How did Ecuador do at the 2011 Copa America?

Ecuador went out in the group stage after a goalless draw with Paraguay and defeats by Venezuela and Brazil. Coach Reinaldo Rueda's longer-term plan paid off, though, as Ecuador qualified for the 2014 World Cup in Brazil.

Keep reading

Articles

Copa America 2011, part five: the contenders, Uruguay and Chile

One side had just finished fourth at the World Cup, the other had dazzled there under Marcelo Bielsa. How Uruguay and Chile shaped up for Argentina 2011, and what happened next.

Read on →Copa America 2011, part five: the contenders, Uruguay and Chile
Articles

Copa America 2011, part two: the outsiders, Mexico and Costa Rica

Two invited nations from outside South America, both clashing with the Gold Cup and both sending youngsters to Argentina. A preview of the guests, and what became of them.

Read on →Copa America 2011, part two: the outsiders, Mexico and Costa Rica
Videos

Uruguay's 1995 triumph in the Copa América

A year after missing the 1994 World Cup, Uruguay hosted the Copa América and beat the world champions Brazil in the final in Montevideo.

Read on →Uruguay's 1995 triumph in the Copa América