
Santiago Silva is a fearsome, snorting bull of a centre-forward: shaven-headed, tall and broad. He can play alone up front, strong enough to hold the ball up and bully defenders, mobile enough to work the channels, and above all he scores. He has scored in his homeland, in Brazil, for Energie Cottbus in Germany and for a run of Argentine clubs. In mid-2011 he had just won the Argentine title at Vélez Sarsfield, with 32 goals in 71 games, and Boca Juniors were said to want him as the successor to Martín Palermo.
Yet Silva is Uruguayan, and before the 2011 Copa América he was nowhere near the national squad. Short of a freak accident at a squad asado that removed every forward but him and the recently overlooked Ernesto Chevantón, he was never going to be called. Uruguay simply did not need him. That is the measure of the team Óscar Tabárez took to Argentina.
Uruguay: a small country with a huge record
For a nation of around three and a half million people, Uruguay's record in international football is astonishing. Before the World Cup existed they won its nearest equivalent, the Olympic football tournament, in 1924 and 1928. Football around the River Plate had grown up in curious isolation in Buenos Aires and Montevideo, and the short passing and outrageous dribbling the Argentines called "la nuestra" had its Uruguayan twin. The two countries contested the first World Cup final in Montevideo in 1930, Uruguay winning 4–2, and in 1950 Uruguay silenced the Maracanã by beating Brazil 2–1 in the deciding match.
Fourth places in 1954 and 1970 followed, but for decades the country lived below the standards its founders had set. The Copa América was where they still shone. Going into 2011 they shared the record of 14 titles with Argentina, and their most recent had come at home in 1995, when a side built around Enzo Francescoli and Daniel Fonseca, with Gus Poyet, Pablo Bengoechea and Sergio Martínez alongside, beat world champions Brazil on penalties in the final.
Sixteen years on, Uruguay looked overdue another, and for the first time in two decades they had a squad capable of it. It was essentially the group that had finished fourth at the 2010 World Cup in South Africa, under the same coach. Tabárez, "el Maestro", was in his second spell in charge, having taken the Francescoli generation to the last 16 at Italia 90, and his team was tactically precise without smothering individual expression.
Forlán, Suárez and Cavani
Uruguay's traditional shape is a 4-3-3, but Tabárez was never a slave to tradition and varied the system around his squad. Its great strength was the forward line, which stood comparison with any in world football.
Diego Forlán, Luis Suárez and Edinson Cavani were the starting three. Each could play more than one role, though the best arrangement looked like Cavani as the fixed point at centre-forward, with Forlán and Suárez buzzing around him, dropping deep and swapping flanks. Cavani was the man in form: 26 goals in 35 games for Napoli that season, including a hat-trick of headers against Juventus. Nicknamed "el Matador", he was strong in the air, quick, two-footed, a fierce striker from distance and an honest worker without the ball. He had nine goals in 25 caps and room to improve that tally.
Suárez, Cavani's team-mate at under-20 level, was a different animal. He dribbled from deep, probed, flicked, drifted wide and cut inside at speed, arriving again and again in dangerous positions, playing one-twos and shooting from outside the box. He had 16 goals in 39 internationals and a well-developed understanding with Forlán.

Forlán's career was a study in steady improvement. He began as an almost old-fashioned inside forward and grew into a player who could lead the line, support a striker, roam as a playmaker (as he did so effectively at the 2010 World Cup, where he was named the tournament's best player) or even play wide. With 29 goals in 73 games he was the side's talisman, and his presence, work rate and leadership mattered as much as the goals.
Behind them came Sebastián "el Loco" Abreu of Botafogo, just three goals behind Forlán on the all-time list and the taker of the nerveless chipped penalty that knocked Ghana out in Johannesburg. Abreu's aerial power was the late-game option. Seba Fernández of Málaga and young Abel Hernández of Palermo offered pace from the bench.
Garra charrúa at the back
With such an attack, Tabárez could afford a workmanlike midfield. He preferred three all-rounders built around Bologna's Diego Pérez, a tireless tackler with a simple, effective pass, usually joined by the equally industrious Egidio Arévalo Ríos of Botafogo and either Napoli's Walter Gargano, the most gifted of the group, or Sebastián Eguren of Sporting Gijón. Porto's Álvaro Pereira sometimes pushed forward down the left. Only one creative midfielder was risked at a time: before the World Cup that had been Nicolás Lodeiro, outstanding against Costa Rica in the play-off, though injuries had ruined his first season at Ajax. Bologna's Gastón Ramírez was the exciting alternative.
Uruguayans speak proudly of "garra charrúa", the claw of the Charrúa, a vanished indigenous people, to explain how such a small country keeps beating bigger ones. It has earned them an occasionally unfair reputation for rough play, and it guarantees a side that works relentlessly. The defence showed it best. Captain Diego Lugano of Fenerbahçe organised it, with Sevilla's Martín Cáceres and Atlético Madrid's Diego Godín covering his lack of pace while his aggression kept them compact. Benfica's Maxi Pereira supplied thrust from right-back, and the unit could switch between a back three and a back four without fuss. The one obvious weakness was in goal, where Lazio's Fernando Muslera mixed fine shot-stopping with the occasional big mistake.
The pre-tournament verdict was a semi-final at least, probably against Brazil or Argentina. There was a nice omen too: the last Copa held in Argentina, in 1987, came with the hosts as reigning world champions, and Uruguay won it.
What happened to Uruguay in 2011
The omen held. Uruguay beat the hosts on penalties in the quarter-final in Santa Fe, saw off Peru 2–0 in the semi-final with two goals from Suárez, and beat Paraguay 3–0 in the final at the Monumental in Buenos Aires, Suárez scoring once and Forlán twice. Suárez was named player of the tournament. The win took Uruguay to 15 titles, making them outright record holders, and Suárez went on to become the country's all-time leading scorer.

Chile: the best generation they had ever produced
Alongside Venezuela and Ecuador, Chile were one of only three CONMEBOL nations never to have won the Copa América. Unlike Venezuela, Chile lives and breathes the game. The Chilean Primera has big, competitive clubs that produce good players, among them Colo-Colo, Universidad de Chile, Cobreloa and Universidad Católica, while the national team, as Chileans tell it, has a long history of bad luck and bad management.
La Roja had appeared at eight World Cups, finishing third as hosts in 1962, but otherwise never got out of a group until 1998. That year the strike partnership of Marcelo Salas and Iván Zamorano, known as "Za-Sa", frightened Italy in a 2–2 draw before Brazil ended the run in the last 16. Chile had missed 1990 and 1994 after the scandal at the Maracanã in 1989, when goalkeeper Roberto Rojas faked an injury after a flare landed near him, his team-mates refused to continue, and television pictures exposed the deception. Rojas was banned for life and Chile were excluded from the 1994 qualifiers.
Their Copa record was a list of near misses: runners-up in 1955, 1956, 1979 and 1987, third as hosts in 1991. At the 2007 tournament they scraped out of the group and were then thrashed 6–1 by a second-string Brazil in the quarter-final.
From Bielsa to Borghi
The man who changed that culture was Marcelo Bielsa. Nicknamed "el Loco" for his obsessive attention to detail, the Argentine took over after the 2007 debacle, promoted the youngsters who had reached the semi-finals of the 2007 Under-20 World Cup (beaten in an ill-tempered tie by an Argentina side with Éver Banega, Ángel Di María and Sergio Agüero), and drilled them in a radical 3-3-1-3. Chile attacked ceaselessly, qualified second for the 2010 World Cup and became one of the most refreshing sides in South Africa. In the first half of their group game against Spain, the eventual champions looked bewildered, and their last-16 defeat to Brazil might have gone differently had Humberto Suazo, the only real centre-forward in the squad, been fit.
Politics at the Chilean federation then led Bielsa to resign, and Claudio Borghi replaced him. Borghi had been an understudy to Diego Maradona in Argentina's 1986 World Cup squad, but his best years were in Chile, winning trophies with Colo-Colo. As a coach he won four consecutive titles at Colo-Colo before winning a title with Argentinos Juniors and enduring a brief, unhappy spell at Boca. He knew Chilean football in a way Bielsa never did, and many of his players had worked under him at club level.
Matías Fernández was the obvious example. The playmaker had been South American Footballer of the Year in 2006 under Borghi at Colo-Colo, driving the club to the Copa Sudamericana final, but never looked fully at ease under Bielsa; the documentary "Ojos Rojos", following the squad through the 2010 qualifiers, includes a scene of Bielsa losing patience with an injured "Mati". Borghi switched to a 3-5-2, let the team sit deeper and break, and Fernández responded with superb free kicks in friendlies against Portugal and Colombia.

The defence, usually led by Cruz Azul's Waldo Ponce, remained the weakest area, and both coaches built protection in front of it. Sevilla's Gary Medel, short and combative, partnered Atalanta's underrated Carlos Carmona as a screen. Arturo Vidal, outstanding at Leverkusen, could play almost anywhere in midfield or defence; he joined Juventus that summer. Udinese's Mauricio Isla and either Mark González of CSKA Moscow or Birmingham City's Jean Beausejour were the aggressive wing-backs.
Up front, the player British fans most wanted to see was Alexis Sánchez of Udinese. A winger under Bielsa, he had been moved into a support striker role by Francesco Guidolin and transformed both his own season and his club's. Quick, strong and inventive, deadly one against one, he had 12 goals in 36 internationals, bettered in the squad only by Suazo's 18 in 45. Barcelona signed him weeks after the tournament.
What happened to Chile, then and later
Chile won their group ahead of Uruguay, then lost 2–1 to Venezuela in the quarter-final in San Juan, a result that fitted their history of bad luck all too neatly. The generation was not finished, though. With Sánchez, Vidal, Medel, Isla and goalkeeper Claudio Bravo, Chile won the Copa América at home in 2015, beating Argentina on penalties in the final in Santiago, and beat Argentina on penalties again in the Centenario final in New Jersey a year later.
Further South American football writing from the same author can be found on GolGolGolGolGol and on his Twitter page. The rest of the series covers the giants, Argentina and Brazil, and Paraguay and Ecuador, the side Uruguay would eventually beat in the final.