Play a quiz
Copa America

Copa America 2011, part two: the outsiders, Mexico and Costa Rica

Two invited nations from outside South America, both clashing with the Gold Cup and both sending youngsters to Argentina. A preview of the guests, and what became of them.

First published 9 Jun ’11 6 min read Articles →
AISmall block of green-shirted fans in a big South American stadium on a cold night (picture made with AI)
Picture made with AI · About our images

Since 1993, every Copa America has included two guest nations from outside South America. The list has included the USA, Honduras, Japan and Canada, who withdrew from the 2001 tournament, along with Argentina, over security concerns about the hosts, Colombia. For the 2011 edition in Argentina, the guests were Mexico and Costa Rica: outsiders in the literal sense, though both Spanish-speaking, which kept the tournament an all-Latin affair.

Both arrived with the same headache. Their own confederation's championship was getting in the way.

Mexico: a squad shaped by the calendar

The big problem for Mexico was timing. CONCACAF, which governs football in North and Central America and the Caribbean, was staging its Gold Cup in the United States in June 2011, just before the Copa began. Mexico were the holders, having won the 2009 edition, and wanted to keep their title against the likes of the USA, Honduras and Costa Rica.

That clash, together with CONCACAF rules on competing in tournaments run by other confederations, meant Mexico sent what was effectively an under-22 team to Argentina. Like an Olympic squad, it was strengthened by five senior players, four of whom had been at the 2010 World Cup. A further complication was the Under-20 World Cup in Colombia, starting five days after the Copa final, which was likely to keep exciting youngsters such as Chivas striker Erik "Cubo" Torres, the man who replaced Javier Hernández in Guadalajara, and Diego Reyes of Club América away from the senior tournament or limit their minutes.

Even so, it was a relatively strong squad, drawn from all of Mexico's biggest clubs. The Mexican league was one of the deepest in Latin America, financially healthy, hugely popular and consistently competitive, and its big clubs produced a steady flow of young talent. Young Mexican players rarely went abroad the way young Argentines did, simply because they did not need to: their clubs could afford to keep and develop them.

AIAdult footballer practising against a wall in a colourful city neighbourhood at sunset (picture made with AI)
Mexico's big clubs rarely let their young talent go abroad early. · Picture made with AI · About our images

An underachieving football nation?

There was a case that Mexico had underachieved. They had qualified for every World Cup since 1994 and reached the round of 16 every time, but never gone further. Whenever they met one of the major powers, as with Argentina in both 2006 and 2010, they went out.

Their record elsewhere was impressive. By 2011 they had won the Gold Cup eight times, finished runners-up in the Copa America in 1993 and 2001, and won the 1999 Confederations Cup at the Azteca, beating Brazil 4–3 in the final. For a country so passionate and so populous, though, the World Cup remained the prize that mattered. The generation breaking through, led by Hernández at Manchester United, looked capable of challenging, and more players moving to European clubs could only help.

Two Europe-based players appeared in the preliminary Copa squad. Arsenal's Carlos Vela was more important to Mexico than to his club, but Arsenal refused permission for him to take part. His likely replacement in the starting line-up was one of the senior players, Rafael Márquez Lugo, a stocky, prolific little striker. Barcelona's Jonathan dos Santos, younger brother of Giovani, was a central midfielder with metronomic passing, the vision and patience to dictate a game and only an eye for goal missing from his repertoire.

Under José Manuel "Chepo" de la Torre, the senior side played a fluid 4-2-3-1 built on quick interplay and sweeping passing moves, and the Copa team was expected to follow suit. Dos Santos and the wingers Edgar Iván Pacheco and Néstor Calderón had the technique for it, while the experienced Jonny Magallón, a national-team regular for a decade, was expected to organise the defence. Pacheco had shone and scored in a 2–0 friendly win over Bosnia and Herzegovina in February 2011.

The draw was unkind. Group C, with Uruguay, Chile and Peru, looked the toughest and most evenly balanced of the three.

Costa Rica: late replacements

Japan had originally been invited as the second guest nation, but the devastating earthquake and tsunami of March 2011 forced them to withdraw, and Costa Rica took their place. The Ticos had played in the Copa three times before, in 1997, 2001 and 2004, reaching the quarter-finals on the last two occasions.

They shared Mexico's Gold Cup problem but found an interesting way round it. The senior squad selected for the Gold Cup, captained by Bryan Ruiz of FC Twente, probably the country's best-known player at the time, travelled to the United States together with the under-22 squad bound for Argentina, training and playing practice games as one group. A few players were expected to feature in both competitions.

Historically, Costa Rica punch above their weight. They had qualified for three World Cups and bloodied a few noses, none more memorably than in the 1–0 win over Scotland in Genoa at Italia 90, and their three Gold Cup titles made them CONCACAF's third most successful nation behind Mexico and the USA.

AIRain-soaked tropical football pitch with forested hills and palm trees behind (picture made with AI)
Costa Rica have long punched above their weight in CONCACAF. · Picture made with AI · About our images

La Volpe's system and a forgiving format

The coach was the Argentine Ricardo La Volpe, who had led Mexico at the 2006 World Cup and managed Boca Juniors, Vélez Sarsfield and a string of Mexican clubs. He liked a 5-3-2 with Brazilian-style wing-backs, effectively a 3-2-3-2 in possession, which left space to exploit behind those advanced full-backs. With a young squad facing hosts Argentina, Colombia and Bolivia in Group A, it was a risky approach.

The format offered some protection. Twelve teams were split into three groups of four. The top two in each group went through to the quarter-finals, along with the two best third-placed sides, so only four of the twelve would go home after the group stage. In theory, a win over Bolivia might be enough for Costa Rica to reach the last eight, even with defeats by Argentina and Colombia.

The squad mixed home-based players with others abroad. Strikers Diego Madrigal of Cerro Porteño, then Copa Libertadores semi-finalists, and Marco Ureña of Kuban Krasnodar in Russia were likely to feature, alongside Diego Estrada, an exciting attacking midfielder who had starred for the country's youth teams. Madrigal had scored the winner in a 1–0 friendly against Nigeria at the end of May. Expectations were modest given the short notice, though plenty had said the same about Denmark before Euro 92, and that turned out rather well.

AIBlank hand-drawn tournament wall chart with group boxes on a cork board (picture made with AI)
Twelve teams, three groups and eight places in the quarter-finals. · Picture made with AI · About our images

How the outsiders fared

Neither guest reached the knockout stage. Mexico's youngsters lost all three group games, to Chile, Peru and Uruguay, each by a single goal. Costa Rica beat Bolivia 2–0 but lost to Colombia and Argentina, and their three points were not enough to finish among the two best third-placed teams. Uruguay went on to win the tournament, beating Paraguay 3–0 in the final in Buenos Aires, a triumph that echoed their 1995 success on home soil (see Uruguay's 1995 Copa America win).

The bigger story for Mexico was elsewhere. The senior side won the 2011 Gold Cup, beating the USA 4–2 in the final, and a year later an under-23 team won Olympic gold at Wembley, beating Brazil 2–1. Several of the players who learned hard lessons in Argentina were part of that success. The World Cup curse proved more stubborn: Mexico went out in the round of 16 again in 2014 and 2018, and in the group stage in 2022.

The rest of the guide covers the minnows, Bolivia and Venezuela, the under-achievers, Colombia and Peru, and the over-achievers, Paraguay and Ecuador. More South American football writing from the author of this guide appears at GolGolGolGolGol and on his Twitter page.

For a test of memory, the Copa America sticker quiz asks for names from earlier editions of the tournament.

Costa Rica's breakthrough came in Brazil in 2014. Drawn with Uruguay, Italy and England, they topped the group, beat Greece on penalties in the last 16 and lost to the Netherlands only on penalties in the quarter-finals, with Bryan Ruiz among their stars. Behind them stood Keylor Navas, who went on to win the Champions League three times with Real Madrid.

Questions and answers

Why did Mexico send a young team to the 2011 Copa America?

The CONCACAF Gold Cup was played in the United States in June 2011, just before the Copa, and Mexico were the holders. Combined with CONCACAF rules on other confederations' tournaments, that meant Mexico sent what was effectively an under-22 side strengthened by five senior players.

Why did Costa Rica replace Japan at the 2011 Copa America?

Japan had been invited as the second guest nation, but the earthquake and tsunami of March 2011 forced them to withdraw. Costa Rica took their place, having previously played in the Copa in 1997, 2001 and 2004.

How did Mexico and Costa Rica do at the 2011 Copa America?

Neither got out of the group. Mexico's youngsters lost all three games by a single goal, to Chile, Peru and Uruguay. Costa Rica beat Bolivia 2–0 but lost to Colombia and Argentina, and their three points were not enough to go through.

What did Mexico win after the 2011 Copa America?

The senior side won the 2011 Gold Cup, beating the USA 4–2 in the final, and a year later an under-23 team won Olympic gold at Wembley by beating Brazil 2–1. Several players who struggled in Argentina were part of that success.

Keep reading

Articles

Copa América 2011, part one: the minnows, Bolivia and Venezuela

The first of six previews of the 2011 tournament in Argentina looks at the two sides given the least chance, and one of them went on to surprise everybody.

Read on →Copa América 2011, part one: the minnows, Bolivia and Venezuela
Articles

Copa America 2011, part three: under-achievers Colombia and Peru

Two football-mad nations with tangled histories and talented squads. Before Argentina 2011, Colombia had Falcao and Peru had Markarian. Then they met in the quarter-finals.

Read on →Copa America 2011, part three: under-achievers Colombia and Peru
Quizzes

Guess the Copa America star from their classic football sticker

Thirty-five faces from South America's championship, the 2011 generation hidden among heroes of tournaments long past.

Play →Guess the Copa America star from their classic football sticker